Re:Silicon Valley’s Safe Space
by tptacek on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:36PM
(#26126609)
Scott Alexander is not a victim of sexual assault; he's the author of a blog that he would rather not have connected to his name. The norms about sexual assault victims in journalism are specific (and they're contentious! Google CJR for examples) and you can't generalize from them.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Silicon Valley’s Safe Space
by NovaJehovah on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:19PM
(#26127039)
In other words: no, you wouldn't feel the same.
He's a blogger, not an assault victim, but his concerns are similar. Avoiding harassment and physical violence against himself and his family. Avoiding negative consequences on his career.
Why are his concerns less valid than anyone else's? "Because I disagree with him" or "because he talks about ideas I don't think should have a platform" aren't good answers. There's no allegation he hurt anyone, did anything illegal, abused his influence, or acted in bad faith. So what's the journalistic purpose of exposing him?
Since we're making absurd comparisons, what about violentacrez, who moderated a subreddit devoted to creepshots of underage girls?
Should his identity have been withheld because it would hurt his career, or he might be harassed?