Here in Vietnam you can buy a DVD of any recent Hollywood movie for 50 cents. Is it a coincidence that the domestic film industry is junk? In the physical world the only way to preempt a "tragedy of the commons" is to restrict the commons. I'd like to think the net is different but current trends suggest otherwise.
Counter anecdote to your anecdote.
EDIT: Actually theres a small phenomena going on that I've recently noticed in the Indian cinema/piracy scene which is worth letting other people know.
Quick background first: Bhojpuri Cinema - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhojpuri_cinema
Bhojpuri is a dialect of Hindi, spoken mostly in the north easter states of India. Bhojpuri cinema was a relatively dead creature, with a small audience and it paled in financial/audience significance compared to your typical bollywood fare.
Now a lot of labor such as security guards, house help, cooks, are immigrants from those states, and of course they speak bhojpuri. They've had to watch hindi cinema when outside of their states though; the opportunity cost of putting up a bhojpuri movie, instead of a bollywood flop, is too high. The choices of bhojpuri speakers were basically Hindi movies or, Hindi movies.
Of late though, cheap color mobile phones, about Rs.1,500 to Rs.3,000 ($25 - $50), coupled with rampant piracy, are allowing that gap to be bridged. Often when I come in late at night, I can catch security watching a movie on a cheap phone.
I wish I had numbers to know how much is being consumed (how much bhojpuri vs regular hindi cinema for example), but I do know that bhojpuri cinema is going to be able to keep and build a stronger network of viewers. The viewers themselves are able to identify and patronize the art form, something which wouldn't have happened otherwise.
TLDR: Piracy and cheap mobile phones are letting niche hindi dialect speakers consume and watch movies which would have been drowned out against bollywood. Considering the size of the populations, its interesting to see how this plays out.
The key driver for film would would have to be box office ticket sales, (i'm going to ignore food, product placements and the like). DVD/Video sales will be a much lower portion of it. Let me see if i can get any numbers... ah found it. -
Numbers are for 2010 and in INR bn (1 USD = 45.0 INR)
Domestic Theatrical: 62.0 Overseas Theatrical: 6.6 Home Video: 2.3 Cable & Satellite Rights: 8.3 Ancillary Revenue Streams: 4.1
I got this from a KPMG report on the Indian media industry for 2011 - http://www.kpmg.com/IN/en/IssuesAndInsights/ThoughtLeadershi...
The relevant info is on page 61
Well I live in Sweden where DVDs/Blue Rays are quite expensive, but still the domestic film industry is still mostly junk. I don't think one factor has much relevance to the other ;)
Original: 100 points
Someone who the original links to: 10 points
Someone else completely unrelated to the original, but housing their content: 1 point
They're constantly crawling. Is there no way for their crawlers to determine the originating source of content?
I do think you might be on to something. If anyone is in a position to help with this issue, it's Google. Wouldn't it be awesome if they did something to help this problem in a big way?
In practice, this won't work, because a targeted spider of, say, the Oatmeal website will be able to grab new material and post it elsewhere (with modified headers a bit earlier than the original...) long before any generalized search engine swings back around again to check for new content.
The incentives all point to content coping as the best business model for a whole group of people. Why bother to create when Google will pay you anyway and often put you above the original content owner.
It doesn't seem to be worth the time to send DMCA requests to the site. It seems like sending DMCA requests to Google might help, but really, some method of cutting off the funding of these sites would be best. Remove the profit motive. Ideally (not practically) it would be nice if Google gave the ad sense money to the original content creator if a DMCA request is filed on that pages search results. Won't work, but somehow this Search -> Ad model creates the problem, the same companies need to step up and fix it, because it seems like there is going to be no search alternatives because of advertising mass.