> Beware the "public shaming" bomb. It's easy to let off, but very hard to defuse if you made a mistake or the issue turned out to be minor and is rapidly resolved.
There's a wikipedia page for the organization: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gpl-violations.org Among other things, it mentions that the website was offline for most of 2015, and while they recovered it, I am not sure if they have been in activity since (whatever their activity is).
Yes. Judging by the reactions here I think most commenters are unfamiliar with Harald Welte, prolific Free Software hacker and one-man GPL defender.
For all the noise out of kernel hackers about doing their own enforcement if needed, so any copyright assignment is not necessary, Harald is one of the very few who actually went through the trouble of doing something to keep the kernel GPL instead of "GPL as lipservice, BSD in practice."
You'd think the Linux Foundation would be all over this, but it looks like they prefer to keep the gravy train rolling (https://www.linuxfoundation.org/join/members/).
- The logo goes to the homepage
- the "gpl-violations.org" link goes to the homepage
- the page title goes to the homepage
- About describes the goal of the project and who's behind it, but not how to access the project... or if that's even a thing.
- The GPL page lists the GPL itself
- FAQ has a drop down... for four pages that I don't have the context to pick from? Who is this site for? The categories also aren't the same. Some are people (Vendors) others are topics (Legal).
Beyond reading those pages, as an individual landing on the page I'm exhausted at trying to find out what gpl-violations.org does.
> The gpl-violations.org project tries to raise public awareness about past and present infringing use(r)s of GPL licensed software.
Yes, but _what do you do_? Email people? Run marketing campaigns?
> The project wants to act as information and communication platform between all parties involved with licensing of free software
Where is this platform? How do I access it? Is your selling point acting as a liaison? If so, why would you not put a big "contact us" button front and center?
Look, I get that you might not want to design your site to look like a brand-new Bay Area SaaS. I don't want you to do what you don't want! I just want you to think about how to best provide info to the people who visit your website (and who might want to join your cause). And, so far, this ain't it!