Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi...
by mike_esspe on Thursday June 02, 2011 @09:55AM
(#2611956)
This is deflation caused by central bank (due to contraction of credit).
There was a deflation during all 19th century, when gold were money, without any ill consequence. And it was a century of growth due to industrial revolution.
s/spend/invest/. I mean, why would anyone spend money on food? There's no storable value! I can dream up silly situations too, y'know.
Meanwhile, there's a bit more to modern economic theory than a single pithy quote. Like, when deflation actually happens, you get this:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Historical_examples
And this is deflation over a short scale. Bitcoin will experience constant, effectively unstoppable deflation every day after 2020.
>Mainstreamers like the leaves-on-the-fire effect of inflation and also like to overlook the fact that stimlus impairs cyclic corrections
Got some numbers on that? I seem to recall basically no problems occurring during periods when inflation rates are 0-10%.
>and detracts from the role of money as a store of value.
Money isn't supposed to be a store of value; the object of money is to facilitate exchange, not to inhibit it. Investments are a store of value. If you want to store value, invest in the S&P 500.
>"When Something Goes Wrong, It Will Die." I found the logic here non-sequiter. Bitcoin will be tested but from what we know about it at the moment, it looks solid.
SHA256 will -never- be broken, that's for sure!
>If we had a period of high inflation, it's reasonable to expect people would trust finite-supply bitcoins over an unending supply of newly-minted, inflating notes.
The medium that is more easily exchanged will be exchanged. Ever wonder why e-gold never took off, even before governments tried to stop it?
Mind you, I really, really want Bitcoin to succeed. I don't like the Federal Reserve and it bothers me that the federal government has control over the money system. However, I'm not going to disregard science to make myself feel better.