Re:Apple redirects Google Safe Browsing traffic through prox...
by sneak on Friday February 12, 2021 @03:51PM
(#26118407)
> The first time someone loses their mind because they forget their phone's PIN and now can't access their wedding photos, which of course they've never backed up anywhere else, it becomes apparent that most people want Apple to be able to access their stuff as long as it's in service of doing something convenient for the person.
This is a false dichotomy.
Apple had invested significantly in doing a form of key escrow with trusted other devices and other users, possibly involving secret sharing with trusted friends-and-family, that would permit users to have end-to-end encrypted data that could still be recovered without Apple having keys.
Apple employs tons of world class cryptography experts, and has designed several end-to-end cryptosystems, and is perhaps the foremost leading expert organization on what comprises good UX "for the rest of us". This is a solvable problem, and the "they can't do e2e because" excuses that people throw up (such as the one you provided) fall down when we see that they had a system ready to go that was ended on the initiative of those who would prefer surveillance.
Even Google figured out a way to do e2e device backups for Android in a privacy-preserving way. Apple is at least as competent as they are at designing cryptosystems, possibly more so.
The technical issue can be solved, but not as long as Apple doesn't want to upset the FBI.
This is a false dichotomy.
Apple had invested significantly in doing a form of key escrow with trusted other devices and other users, possibly involving secret sharing with trusted friends-and-family, that would permit users to have end-to-end encrypted data that could still be recovered without Apple having keys.
The FBI nixed the plan, and Apple obeyed.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusiv...
Apple employs tons of world class cryptography experts, and has designed several end-to-end cryptosystems, and is perhaps the foremost leading expert organization on what comprises good UX "for the rest of us". This is a solvable problem, and the "they can't do e2e because" excuses that people throw up (such as the one you provided) fall down when we see that they had a system ready to go that was ended on the initiative of those who would prefer surveillance.
Even Google figured out a way to do e2e device backups for Android in a privacy-preserving way. Apple is at least as competent as they are at designing cryptosystems, possibly more so.
The technical issue can be solved, but not as long as Apple doesn't want to upset the FBI.