Can't the same be said for people who bought Apple or Google stocks early on?
It is of course possible that there can be a bubble of expectations in a kind of echo chamber that cause a stock to act like a Ponzi scheme, but ultimately over time there must be returns. The return can be as a stock price rise (but that can't go on forever) or dividends; if the cost[1] of the money invested in the stock doesn't match the return over time, then people will sell the stock and it will fall in price. If too much of the stock price is formed from aspirational expectations of the future (i.e. a bubble), then the price fall may be drastic.
[1] Money has a cost; for example, compared with the interest rate on a risk-free government bond. If an investment isn't making at least that much, it's losing money.
> Ownership of a stock is a claim on the net value and future profit of the company.
Ownership of currency is a claim on the net value and future profit of the currency. How does this address OP?
> A share, meanwhile, is a direct claim on things themselves. What if you buy a share of an ETF?
Alternatively: the profits generated by Apple and Google would argue otherwise.
How can having your assets increase in value be harmful? Traders already account for many stock variables, why would deflation be any different?
> and think about what that would mean - the bank pays you to borrow money from it.
Oh no, not that :P
> "when something goes wrong, it will die"
Sort of like hyper inflation?
> they don't understand that the value of money is a product of supply and demand
They also understand when supply is in control by a few bankers, so is the demand. Who do you trust to ensure supply isn't ramped up: your friendly banker, or math? This isn't hypothetical either http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation
In an inflationary scenario, money is declining in value. People with a lot of it are actively looking for ways to put it to work, otherwise they'll end up poorer. But if the money is not losing value over time, and is in fact appreciating, what incentive do they have to put their capital to work? They need much larger returns on investment to make up for the loss of their existing risk-free return.
[1] For bank, read anyone who could lend to or finance you.
Why do people invest in stocks when they can play it safe in a bond market? They have a different appetite for risk.
I do see your point, a constantly inflating money supply encourages people to invest. The flip side to that is, are the investments worth it? Inflation is an artificial incentive to invest, which some believe is the cause of bubbles. Remember all those stupid investments in the dot-com bubble? Some believe it's because money was too cheap.
Similarly, an individual will deposit money in a bank rather than keep it under their mattress only if the bank offers returns in excess of what it gets sitting in the mattress.
Since at the moment there is no FBDIC, as an individual you must also balance the risk of depositing in the bank against the return they offer.
Ponder the implications of bread jumping to an effective price of $25 a loaf. That can and has happened in deflationary collapses, as the reserve fraction jumps toward 100% (due to credit panic).
In your story, I would attribute the $25 a loaf bread to the credit panic, not the resultant of a consumers increase in purchasing power -- such as the expected deflation in BitCoins.
2) Deflation for a primary store of value in an economy is definitely a bad thing; not least, because it does weird things like causing the value of debts to increase over time, potentially to the point of requiring negative interest; and think about what that would mean - the bank pays you to borrow money from it. Bitcoin probably isn't going to become that, though, so I think it is less of a cause for concern.
3) Convertibility is a systemic problem because it's a confidence game. If the value of bitcoin is on a downward spiral rather than an upward spiral, then you would expect fewer buyers, and those buyers would pay less for declining assets. Paying less in turn sets the market value lower; it becomes cyclical.
And that's where (4) comes in. The reason "when something goes wrong, it will die" is a valid point is because of contagion and panic selling, and the reduction in the number of buyers in the market. It makes perfect sense to me, because it's the exact reverse analogue of why bitcoin has a built-in bootstrap advantage.
I'm getting the impression that people who like Bitcoins are the same kind of people who think gold has an intrinsic worth as a currency, rather than a commodity; in other words, they don't understand that the value of money is a product of supply and demand, no matter whether fiat or specie. Don't forget that 80% of gold production is used in jewellery and industry, rather than bullion etc. What fiat money has going for it is a degree of control to get out of systemic problems.