News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comparison of Rust async and Linux thread context switch ... by scottlamb on Friday February 12, 2021 @10:10AM (#26114438)
> You can also have lower RAM overhead per thread if you choose a smaller stack space.

No, this is about as low as it gets. As the author explained, "the kernel only allocates physical memory to a stack as the thread touches its pages, so the initial memory consumption of a thread in user space is actually only around 8kiB."

The smallest possible page size (on x86-64) is 4 KiB, and you can't share pages between thread stacks, [1] so you can't go below 4 KiB of physical memory usage per thread. I'm not exactly sure how the author got to 8 KiB; maybe they meant "for each userspace thread" rather than "memory used in userspace" and are counting kernel memory too. I'm pretty sure the kernel uses at least 4 KiB per userspace thread (for a stack of its own, among other overhead).

Green threads won't take you below 4 KiB either, for the same reason.

[1] Without some custom ABI that guards against stack overflow in a different way. Golang has a custom ABI (I'm not sure exactly if this is why), and interoperability with C suffers, so this isn't an approach I'd love for Rust.

There are no comments on this comment yet.