News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should random() be banned? by kortex on Friday February 12, 2021 @08:54AM (#26113625)
This just kind of proves GP's point. Random APIs usually tell you what the RNG is, but not the why/how. Most people don't care if it's /dev/(u)random, Mersenne twister, PCG, LFSR, LCG, RDRAND, etc. They care about roughly 4 attributes:

- Is it good for crypto

- Is it fast

- Is it reproducible

- Is it portable

But fundamentally, it's about the use case and interface:

- I need secure random (strong, slow, secure)

- I need Monte Carlo (good enough, fast, reproducible)

- I need chaotic behavior for my game/stress test/back off protocol (usually can be barely random, fast, reproducible)

I think calling the last case InsecureRandom or RandomEnough is reasonable to convey "don't use me for secure purposes".

There are no comments on this comment yet.