Re:What you can learn about medieval Europe if you focus on ...
by hnick on Thursday February 11, 2021 @11:07PM
(#26110634)
I think this is actually an interesting point because the US did lose the war but if the winner writes history, then why do so many think they won?
You have to look beyond the war. VN is doing well now, but overall the US is far richer and more powerful. So they are the "winner" in that sense and can project their view accordingly.
Re:What you can learn about medieval Europe if you focus on ...
by el_dev_hell on Friday February 12, 2021 @12:37AM
(#26111032)
> I think this is actually an interesting point because the US did lose the war but if the winner writes history, then why do so many think they won?
How common is that belief on a whole?
In Vietnam or China, it's common knowledge (and celebrated) that Vietnam won the war.
In the US, I can't imagine talking to someone over 40 that's unaware of how the war ended.
Re:What you can learn about medieval Europe if you focus on ...
by lovemenot on Friday February 12, 2021 @08:21AM
(#26113312)
>> In Vietnam or China, it's common knowledge (and celebrated) that Vietnam won the war.
China celebrates Vietnam winning that war? Perhaps, but it'd be pretty surprising. Vietnam won it in spite of China. (The Soviet Union was a huge help though).
Happy New Year to both Vietnamese and Chinese peoples.
Re:What you can learn about medieval Europe if you focus on ...
by marcodiego on Friday February 12, 2021 @07:51AM
(#26113080)
In US culturally influenced zones, like Brazil, most people think Vietnam lost the war. Most people I've talked to about it were surprised when I told them how the war ended.
Re:What you can learn about medieval Europe if you focus on ...
by mc32 on Thursday February 11, 2021 @11:11PM
(#26110657)
From the PoV of domino theory, one supposes we did ultimately win with the fall of the USSR and thus the COMINT ceased to be a mortal threat to western socio-economic values.
Re:What you can learn about medieval Europe if you focus on ...
by hnick on Thursday February 11, 2021 @11:21PM
(#26110712)
Yes indeed. Dominoes and Matryoshka dolls - the smaller wars within the overarching cold war, which the US did win, despite losing some of the smaller but deadlier wars.
Re:What you can learn about medieval Europe if you focus on ...
by loopz on Friday February 12, 2021 @12:58AM
(#26111119)
USSR lost to itself and its mortal corruption culminating in Chernobyl. US lost the moral war in VN, but learned to play to its strengths after that, to later outplay USSR as a whole.
Re:What you can learn about medieval Europe if you focus on ...
by notahacker on Friday February 12, 2021 @06:06AM
(#26112393)
History isn't written so much by the "winners" as "the people left in charge after the war". If the US and its South Vietnamese allies had won the war, the post-war characterisation of certain figures, philosophies and motivations in Vietnam would have been very different. Vietnam didn't however, win the war decisively enough to force a change of government to the US, and it suited the politicians still in charge of the US to downplay how important preventing communism from spreading in southeast Asia had once been and focus on how Cold War strategy switched to different theatres and approaches.
>”... told only from the winner's point of view is what makes a lot of people not know that the US lost Vietnam war.”
This is confusing. VN winning means people don’t understand the US losing? Or VN wining meant they wanted others to believe the US won the war? Or the US actually lost but never the less your assertion doesn’t apply?