Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by zarify on Thursday June 02, 2011 @02:12AM
(#2610927)
I wasn't so much suggesting that touch was the future, as suggesting that nowhere was the future if they keep lugging about compatibility for the last 6 or 7 (major) versions of the OS, all the while looking at radically changing the way things work. This is the approach that brought us Windows 3.1 and 95.
Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by sapper2 on Thursday June 02, 2011 @05:42AM
(#2611290)
Don't forget, Win 3.1 and 95 were a HUGE commercial success.
Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by pragmatic on Thursday June 02, 2011 @10:27AM
(#2612081)
Windows 3.1 and 95 were _fantastic_ in their day. You might not be old enough to remember DOS programs...
Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by zarify on Thursday June 02, 2011 @09:34PM
(#2614811)
I remember DOS programs just fine. In fact, thanks to today's technology, I don't even need to be old enough to remember them, I'm still living with some of them ;) [slight exaggeration sure, but not excessively so IMO]
My point wasn't so much the advances that 3.1 and 95 were or weren't, it's that each had fairly impressive improvements in the UI, but were still veneers bolted on to the last OS. I can appreciate them wanting legacy support since their cash cow is the business sector, but in doing so they limit their scope for advancement.
Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by nwatson on Thursday June 02, 2011 @02:17AM
(#2610940)
if touch is not "forward" then at least the mouse is definitely "backward". the ideal PARC machine would have been keyboard + touch, not keyboard + mouse. "touch" is interaction with something approaching the real world as it's been known since hunter-gatherer times. the "mouse" is just an artifice to make up for technology that didn't exist in the '70's/early-'80's.
the only thing missing for business apps on iPad form factor is quick text entry. we should drop the mouse. for precise detailed work one could use a stylus. touch is the ideal.
Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by cageface on Thursday June 02, 2011 @02:30AM
(#2610978)
The problem with touch is that's a coarse-resolution input. You can be much, more precise with a mouse and hence have denser UIs. For "pro" apps this is a must.
Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by nwatson on Friday June 03, 2011 @01:26AM
(#2615263)
Again, as I said, for fine-grained work one can use a stylus.
Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by cageface on Friday June 03, 2011 @06:49AM
(#2615829)
Sure, but as a UI designer you have to privilege one input device. You can't design the same interface for touch and a stylus/mouse.
Re:Why Windows 8 Is Fundamentally Flawed as a Response to th...
by sid0 on Thursday June 02, 2011 @03:48AM
(#2611111)
I'd like to see you aim in an FPS with touch.
Also MS's decision to maintain legacy support is their biggest asset. If MS suddenly cut off a huge portion of their past compatibility, and hence established application base, then there is a MUCH bigger risk people will jump ship to Linux or Mac since they need to change up their apps anyhow. Familiarity breeds loyalty, even if sometimes begrudgingly.
They key is will the performance be reasonable on "mobile" hardware. The performance of portable hardware is advancing at a rapid pace but I'm not quite sure it's ready yet (even in a year from now) to run a desktop/touch merged Windows code base. That is where MS is taking a big gamble to me.