News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by ajross on Thursday February 11, 2021 @05:20PM (#26108185)
Software/design issues requiring hardware recalls are routine in the industry, though. There's really nothing notable about this particular issue at all, except that it involves "consumer-like" devices that posters here understand and feel expert on. We all think that "we'd never have done something this dumb", so therefore it's an easy shot to take where esoterica about engine control PCBs isn't something we have the confidence to second guess.

(Needless to say, we totally would have made the same kind of mistake, and probably do so every day.)

The only meaningful ding on Tesla here is #4 above: clearly this was a design flaw and should have been a recall from the start, not a customer-financed repair.

Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by perl4ever on Thursday February 11, 2021 @09:44PM (#26110210)
>There's really nothing notable about this particular issue at all, except that it involves "consumer-like" devices that posters here understand and feel expert on

I think you're off base here; it's the very fact of Tesla using "consumer grade" hardware that is the (notable) problem. The people who "would have made the same mistake" are qualified to pass judgment if they know they are not qualified to develop automotive grade systems.

Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by ajross on Thursday February 11, 2021 @10:18PM (#26110408)
I don't think that holds. In fact while longer-wear flash devices do exist in the market, the design mistake here would have driven any feasible part to failure. While you can argue that choosing consumer parts was "a" mistake, it wasn't the one that caused this failure, which was a software/integration thing.
Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by mlyle on Thursday February 11, 2021 @11:16PM (#26110678)
If you had twice the writes per cell, the life would be 10 years instead of 5. Still wasteful, but...

And if you stepped up to something with effective wear levelling and a bit more capacity, instead, this bad design could have lasted forever.

Or if you socketed the eMMC, it would have been no big deal.

Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by neuralRiot on Friday February 12, 2021 @04:34PM (#26118810)
I think the biggest mistake here is the drivetrain depending on a device which is known to fail (eMMC) even without the logging problem (why not using a separate device for the logging?) it would eventually fail, other manufacturers have similar problems, (Mazda, Ford, Mercedes) but you just lose the audio system.
Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by ajross on Friday February 12, 2021 @04:58PM (#26119030)
> drivetrain depending on a device which is known to fail

Uh... the drive train itself is "known to fail". Everything wears out. Everything breaks. You just aren't surprised when your transmission needs rebuilding or your brakes or shocks need replacement because those are "car things" you've been conditioned are normal. Well, electromigration is just another kind of normal wear and tear to be designed into the device.

And it's the design here that was at fault, having incorrectly planned for the replacement rate. But there's absolutely nothing weird about building cars out of parts that fail over time!

Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by mlyle on Friday February 12, 2021 @05:15PM (#26119159)
The drivetrain doesn't fail when eMMC does. A whole lot of stuff that you'd normally do on the touchscreen is inaccessible, though.
Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by nraynaud on Thursday February 11, 2021 @06:13PM (#26108794)
I certainly have shipped dodgy stuff knowingly for lack of time to do better. "This is a prototype, we'll apply the Chinese warranty, if it's broken we'll replace the unit". I would ship non-UV cables to outdoors stuff, because I had no time to select and order a better one, I shipped an outdoor temperature sensor cover that was not open to the air enough and was just tracking the sun. The only red lines were thunder and fire. I don't want to start a fire, and I don't want to conduct the thunder.

But I did that way earlier than Tesla in the process.

Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by ajross on Thursday February 11, 2021 @06:23PM (#26108884)
Yeah, but it's not a single person or single decision. They went with consumer eMMC, and probably had a justification showing that they'd never need replacement for 30 years of use or whatever. But then someone else overfilled the partition, leaving not enough space for the hardware wear leveling to work in, which over-wears the available space. (No idea what the filesystem choice was, some are more susceptible to this than others). And then a third party decided to ship with the logging settings set to dump all sorts of junk to storage that wasn't needed on a production device.

None of those are particularly boneheaded in isolation. It's just a bug. Bugs just happen.

(But again: design bugs should be recalls and not repairs)

Re:Tesla Recalls Cars with EMMC Failures, Calls Part a ‘Wear... by lupire on Friday February 12, 2021 @08:55AM (#26113631)
> Chinese warranty, if it's broken we'll replace the unit"

That's the mass production warranty for integrated objects. Calling it "Chinese" is just weird unless you are calling attention to a claim that only china does mass production anymore.

For cars, we have the "extended warranty" which is just a bet that the car won't fail to much on average.

Same for hard drives with 3 vs 5 yr warranties.