Re:Products vs. Protocols: What Signal got right
by Zash on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:06PM
(#26104109)
That's why Snikket has a focus on easy invites that automate on-boarding and contact creation.
Other parts of the XMPP ecosystem also have easy invites that can be shared via QR code, SMS or any other messenger. Example: https://yax.im/i/#[email protected] or https://conversations.im/i/[email protected] See also https://yaxim.org/blog/2020/01/31/yaxim-0-dot-9-9-fosdem-edi...
The problem with just a username, is that's not what you need to converse with ANYONE in XMPP land, you need the full XMPP address, and last I checked, no client makes that easy for you to figure out. The full XMPP address should be easy to find as that's what you actually need. Just a username doesn't work, give up on only a username being all you need, it isn't.
I think doing invites from a tech savvy snikket server instance makes sense FOR THAT USE CASE.
For Tito's Grandma, where Tito & Grandma are not tech savvy people.. that's not easy. Tito gets setup on server Y and Grandma gets setup on server Z, and neither of them can talk to each other because the client only shows the 'username'.
Again, I haven't knowingly used Snikket, but last time I played in XMPP, it was non-trivial, even for a tech savvy person.