Re:Dependency Confusion: How I Hacked Into Apple, Microsoft ...
by korijn on Thursday February 11, 2021 @05:39PM
(#26108361)
In obvious cases like that, I agree with you. In real life however my dependencies are rarely that simple.
So let's imagine a REST API library that needs disk and network access to do it's work. How do I know it doesn't abuse my permission?
And what about its transient dependencies?
Let's say I'm using a `left-pad` function that someone else wrote, and I'm using a system in which modules aren't granted any authority except what you give them. If I then call
...I don't really have to worry that it'll go rummaging around my filesystem for my private keys and exfiltrate them somewhere. After all, I didn't give it access to my filesystem or the network! (Side-channel attacks notwithstanding, things get thorny real quick at that point.)Now, you still have to worry about the function not doing what being correct - it might return an empty string, it might go into an infinite loop, etc - but you've tremendously reduced the scope of what this module could do if the developer were malicious.