Re:Dependency Confusion: How I Hacked Into Apple, Microsoft ...
by jonny_eh on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:43PM
(#26092327)
> Of course JS isn't a great language for this. A malicious program could spider the object graph looking for something valuable.
Deno can provide extra syntax or annotations for imports to allow the dev to explicitly allow permission per-import. These can be in the source code, or in a config file.
Re:Dependency Confusion: How I Hacked Into Apple, Microsoft ...
by kevincox on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:50PM
(#26092426)
How would this work exactly? How do you control what module's permission to use for any IO?
For example what if you have a callback library that calls a function that does IO? What if you pass an IO function directly as a callback? (For example File.close) If it is the file where the call is textually written how do you handle dynamic calls? (or are they forbidden).
I think the capability model is probably the right one here.
Of course JS isn't a great language for this. A malicious program could spider the object graph looking for something valuable. You would have to be very careful to keep these objects hidden. And a container library would have huge amounts of access with it needs none. (For example if you want to store a hashmap of open sockets)
A stronger typed language like Rust or Haskell could do better, as you container library can be prevented from casting T to File. However even that is not enough as you can just manually cast a pointer if you somehow know what type it is. (And there is a small amount of reflection that can do this even in safe code).