News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by jasongill on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @05:29PM (#26083302)
Not that you're wrong that JD has a huge following, but over the past 5 decades they have basically gone the way of American auto manufacturers: everyone knows that their products are inferior to the "imports" (which are all made in America anyway), and they survive by brand recognition, big head start establishing a dealer network, and servicing product categories that nobody else does.

Kubota is basically the Toyota to John Deere - they are eating JD's lunch in quality and buyer/owner perception (as well as sales volume) in the "small cars" segment, and is quickly moving up-market. Kubota doesn't sell combines yet, for example, and they are still not outselling JD in anything other than compact tractors, but the people who buy those (myself included) will never go back to JD. Deere has been plagued with quality issues and where they do innovate with some flashy features at times (just like the F-150 does vs the Tundra), they seem to often cause more trouble than they can be worth.

I would say that (depending on the "trade war" of course) Kubota and the "imports" will surpass JD in total units sold some time in the next decade and then start eroding their dominance in the large tractor market in the following decade, if not sooner.

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by mikey_p on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @06:44PM (#26084081)
The whole import argument doesn't really hold up very well. The only companies that really challenge John Deere at the high end of the market are Case, Claas and Fendt. The US market is still dominated by the US manufacturers due to the sheer logistics of importing these large machines, and the lack of dealer networks.

Also, you'd be kidding yourself if you think Claas or Fendt are any less reliant on proprietary software at this point.

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by mjevans on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:48PM (#26085257)
I've heard the lack of dealer networks is one of the key points against competitors. Those networks serve as a parts and systems replacements logistics multiplier. Implicit 'insurance' against crop loss is built in to that high price.

Logically some kind of insurance against opportunity loss due to equipment issues, and/or better logistics supply for parts would probably aid competition.

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:09PM (#26085343)
Yes, and the imports similarly failed to challenge Ford, GM, and Dodge muscle cars of the 60s and 70s. But Toyota, Nissan, Honda etc. didn't start at the high end, either.

The US market is dominated by US manufacturers due to inertia, all manufacturers are following the same formula of foreign subcomponents and domestic steel.

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by jet_32951 on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @05:56PM (#26083630)
Yes. I had a Kubota B7800 for about fifteen years. The JD competitor was made by Iseki, priced higher, and known for hydraulic system problems. The choice was easy and I never regretted it.

At the same time I bought the Kubota I worked for a company that made automatic steering systems one could retrofit to many tractors... but not JD, who were already controlling their hydraulic system access.

Never bought JD, stuck with Kubota.

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by nitrogen on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @06:07PM (#26083728)
but not JD, who were already controlling their hydraulic system access.

I've only ever used an ancient Farmall tractor where the hydraulic system is just a bunch of generic hoses and levers. How does JD limit hydraulic system access? Do they use proprietary fittings? Digital controls that will refuse to engage the hydraulic pump if a line is spliced?

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by jet_32951 on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @06:40PM (#26084044)
SAE J1939 specifies an optional encrypted word, and JD used that for hydraulic controls IIRC.

Kudos on keeping the Farmall. My gf at the time had a Ford 8N and I loved that thing on her land, but 2wd didn't work well at my place.

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by kls on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @07:12AM (#26088178)
I still have my great grandfathers Farmall Cub, it was the first tractor he and my grandfather bought for the citrus farm they homesteaded in FL, when he passed my grandfather restored it. When my grandfather sold the farm it was the only tractor he kept. My grandfather passed on in 2013 so I brought it down to my property in the FL Keys and use it as a yard tractor here. They just don't build machinery like those old tractors anymore.
Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by mikey_p on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @06:45PM (#26084093)
It's digitally controlled, no more physical levers connected to valves.
Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by kls on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @06:59AM (#26088095)
This is true when you get to smaller tractor classes, but when you get up to the big specialized tractors like combines, Kubota and the others just really are not in the game in the US, it's dominated by a few players and they all have closed proprietary systems. Caterpillar and a few other players do this is the specialized heavy equipment game, it's pretty much the same playbook.

As well their really is no comparison, to JD's high end fleet tractors to the ones they sell to compete with New Holland or Kubota, they are different lines with different quality controls. It gets even worse when you get down to personal lawn tractors. They are basically just rebadging commodity built hardware at that level.

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by louky on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:03PM (#26085620)
My father insisted on getting a brand-new Massey Ferguson compact tractor. Way overpriced but he's got brand loyalty from many decades back.

Wouldn't even hear of a Kubota.

Re:Farmers are having to hack their own tractors to make re... by mycall on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:50PM (#26085840)
I call my Kubota 4.5kW my ole trusty. You can't kill it.