News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea by hugh3 on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @01:25PM (#2608283)
except they are extremely expensive and hard to defend. They are great for projecting power against countries that can't defend against them, but extremely ineffective against a remotely comparable force. They are an obvious high priority

There are 190-odd countries in the world. The US Navy's aircraft carriers are extremely effective against at least 185 of 'em.

All the countries with a "remotely comparable force" also have nuclear weapons, so if the US ever winds up in a full-on shooting war with one of them then it's all over for both sides anyway.

No aircraft carrier has actually been sunk since World War 2. So they can't be that vulnerable.

Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea by latch on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @09:17PM (#2610187)
No aircraft carrier has actually been sunk since World War 2. So they can't be that vulnerable.

Isn't that like saying Hoover Dam has never been destroyed, so it can't be that vulnerable?

I'm not sure that there have been serious attempts to destroy either (is my point).

Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea by philwelch on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @05:01PM (#2609322)
1000 anti-ship missiles cost far less than an aircraft carrier with crew and aircraft aboard. There are a number of non-nuclear powers with the ability to launch 1000 anti-ship missiles against an American task force.
Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea by hugh3 on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @05:33PM (#2609453)
How would you launch a thousand anti-ship missiles? And how would you get that launch platform within range of a US aircraft carrier?

Bear in mind that anything capable of launching a thouand anti-ship missiles will be one of the things the USAF will destroy within the first few hours of the war.

Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea by masklinn on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @06:21PM (#2609661)
> How would you launch a thousand anti-ship missiles?

With a hundred small boats

> And how would you get that launch platform within range of a US aircraft carrier?

With civilians on board

> Bear in mind that anything capable of launching a thouand anti-ship missiles will be one of the things the USAF will destroy within the first few hours of the war.

Yep, nothing better to start a war on the right foot than civilian massacre.