News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by chollida1 on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:56AM (#26078170)
The hard part about this case will be that both sides have a decent arguement.

The way Robinhood displays this info is no different than most other brokers. I work at a fund and spent alotof time "smoothing" out our pnl to take care of issues like this where one side of a option basket gets exercised and the other side hasn't yet.

By that regard Robinhood is in good standing as they follow the industry practice.

The otherside of the coin is that option trading, especially for retail, often requires

1) the person requesting the ability to trade options explicitly.

2) a phone call that screens the user for a basic understanding.

3) the user has enough money in their account to be able to exercise any options that they buy, ie you buy 1 Call contract for Tesla that gives you the right to buy 100 shares at the strike, do you have enough money in your account to buy 100 shares of tesla? If not then you can't buy

4) don't allow users to sell options unless they have a large capital margin in their account, and often don't allow them to write contracts at all.

And robinhood has to have phone support for issues like this. This may be the thing that sinks them. Sometimes when dealing with money and contracts with time limits you need to talk to someone immediately on the phone. Robinhood is at fault here.

this poor adult chose suicide, a permanent solution to a temporary problem. if he had just waited a few days or talked to his parents.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by fatnoah on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:10AM (#26078331)
The article has less information than some others. Here's a bit that's probably a key to the family's lawsuit:

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/alex-kearns-robinhood-trader-su...

>Later that night, at 3:26 a.m., the company sent an automated email demanding Alex take "immediate action," requesting a payment of more than $170,000 in just a few days.

Alex was then unable to contact customer support via phone and email. The day after his suicide, he was sent this email:

>"Great news!" The email read, "We're reaching out to confirm that you've met your margin call and we've lifted your trade restrictions. If you have any questions about your margin call, please feel free to reach out. We're happy to help!"

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by RHSeeger on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:12AM (#26079179)
> Alex was then unable to contact customer support via phone and email

From what I read, he reached out to support (late at night) and they responded the next day (letting him know all was well?). Admittedly, this is after he killed himself, but it does seem to be a perfectly reasonable response time. It doesn't sound like they're in the wrong in that regard.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by tedunangst on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:28AM (#26078545)
That's a pretty typical email to get from a broker. If you want to hold on to the stock that's been put into your account for some reason, you have to pay for it. Otherwise they'll settle things up for you.
Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by leetcrew on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:04AM (#26078270)
> 3) the user has enough money in their account to be able to exercise any options that they buy, ie you buy 1 Call contract for Tesla that gives you the right to buy 100 shares at the strike, do you have enough money in your account to buy 100 shares of tesla? If not then you can't buy

I don't quite understand this one. first of all, if I buy a call I don't have to exercise it. if I don't have enough cash to exercise it, can't I just sell the contract itself for roughly the same gain? if so, why should there be a capital requirement to buy one?

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:28AM (#26078543)
> if I buy a call I don't have to exercise it

I'm assuming the loss was on options he wrote, not bought. Options buyers have a choice. Options writers don't.

There was an offsetting option or long or short position. But the options he wrote were exercised before those hedges settled. Robinhood's UI correctly showed the P&L at that time (though it could have gone further). The user didn't understand it. Robinhood then incorrectly sent a demand letter for $170,000 and didn't provide any means by which the user could contact them.

(Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer and none of this is even legal analysis let alone advice.)

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by ethbr0 on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:09AM (#26078325)
I assume proof of "good faith."

If you have no skin in the game, and can buy literally infinite numbers of options, with no intention to execute, that breaks a lot of things (not least, because of how you force counterparties to behave).

Afaik, abusing this is a big part of the Reddit pump-and-dump train playbook.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by madamelic on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:15AM (#26078391)
No, you can't.

You pay a premium for the option. One of the massive benefits of trading options is being able to leverage your money.

If you can't afford to buy 100 shares, you can buy an option for 100 shares for much cheaper, with the intention to flip the option later to either a bagholder or someone who wants to exercise it.

This method isn't even exclusive to retail traders.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by leetcrew on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:12AM (#26078354)
you do have skin in the game though. you have to actually pay the premium for all those options. if you have no intention to exercise them (or at least sell the contracts before they expire), you are just throwing your own money away. if the premium is priced appropriately, this shouldn't be a problem for the counterparty. if not, it's kinda their own fault. am I missing something?
Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by Spooky23 on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:18AM (#26078420)
I think what you're missing is that you understand how options work. A 20 year old futzing around with Robinhood on his phone probably doesn't.

Robinhood removes the friction associated with getting authorized for things like options trading. It's like taking a 16 year old to the craps table at a casino. IMO, it's irresponsible, both as a service provider and a stakeholder in the broader market to make that type of activity available to people with no money.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by leetcrew on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:40AM (#26078712)
mainly I'm curious why chollida1 specifically thinks there ought to be a capital requirement to buy a call. I can see why you might not want to let a 20yo buy calls on margin (or anything on margin for that matter), but that wasn't specified in the original post. chollida1 seems to be a lot more experienced than me, so perhaps there is something to learn here.

in the unfortunate case of this guy who took his life, robinhood apparently gave him access to a large amount of margin and the ability to write options. that seems crazy to me. I doubt schwab would let me do that, and I've been trading with them for years.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by chollida1 on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:01AM (#26079027)
Well the biggest reason alot of retail focused brokers dont' let you buy things yhou don't have the money to buy is what happens if you hold to expiry?

If its out of the money no big deal, you lose your money, what happens if its in the money?

Do they force you to exercise? If so then you owe them money that isn't in your account

Do they sell it for you? If so at what time? what if there is no offsetting bid for your option? What if they sell it and you had planned on exercising?

This just opens the brokerage up to all sorts of law suits eeven if their terms of service clearly aly out what they'll do.

There just is not always a cut and dry best option for what to do with options before they expire.

What happens if they sell an ITM option but it expires out of the money?

Forcing the user to have money to exercise their options makes it clear and easy, no guessing on when to sell the option, no worrying there wont' be a market for the option, etc.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by leetcrew on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:15AM (#26079234)
as long as they don't let my ITM option expire without doing anything, I don't think I would complain. but I see why a retail broker might not want to open this can of worms now. thanks for the breakdown.
Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by aparsons on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:17AM (#26078413)
Disagree on 3. There is no obligation to buy. Agree on 4 that options you sell need to be covered.
Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by Yabood on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:50AM (#26078853)
On number 4, I believe most brokers don’t allow you to trade options right away, you have to ask for permission before your account is approved for covered options trading (writing/selling options for stock you own, blocks of 100 shares for each option contract). To write options for stock you don’t own (this called naked), you have to ask for another approval. Usually both approvals require some online screening.
Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by ainiriand on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:59AM (#26078208)
Well, not sure about industry practice, my knowledge is limited, but when I opened my trading account I was presented with some questions to assess my understanding.

For different products I get-together different questions if I want to enable them. This is with degiro.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by Zevis on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:10AM (#26078334)
I recently went through all of these tests and they're extremely trivial. I got through them with barely any knowledge about the topic. Even though I can now do options trading, I'm not going to touch it or anything like it until I've put in far more independent research, if at all.
Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by madamelic on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:24AM (#26078491)
Buying options really isn't a problem. Your losses are capped at your premium if the options expire worthless.

Selling options is where it gets _very_ dicey afaik. It seems like the person in question was selling covered options which is the safer way afaik.

But yeah, you shouldn't be super scared of buying options. Selling options, in my opinion, requires more understanding.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by holstvoogd on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:35AM (#26078642)
That I can recommend. It is extremely easy to loose money with it and end up with _nothing_.

Especially the heavily leverage products can go from +100% to -100% in hours. And then your money is just gone. And you have nothing.

Re:Robinhood sued by family of stock trader who killed himself by jhowell on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:19AM (#26078440)
> this poor adult chose suicide... if he had just waited a few days or talked to his parents.

Independent dependent?