Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea
by latch on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @11:55AM
(#2607834)
This isn't the scale I'm talking about. You don't need a fleet of $500 million USD submarines.
11 US aircraft carriers? 11 missiles. $100+Billion vs $15 Million. 30000 soldiers vs 0.
During the cold war this is the strategy that Russia took - let the US build expensive ships, they build [relatively] cheap missiles. The Chinese are doing the same with the Dong Feng missiles.
Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea
by philwelch on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @05:12PM
(#2609370)
One missile won't get through. You don't encounter a carrier by itself--it has a combat air patrol, one or two Aegis cruisers, and two or three Aegis destroyers. Each Aegis system can track 100 targets at a time and launch countermeasures.
However, missiles do scale well. Even 1000 missiles will cost much less than the carrier and will almost certainly take it down.
Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea
by latch on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @08:00PM
(#2609949)
A single supersonic or soon-to-exist (india is mass-producing) hypersonic missile might get through. But yes, even if 1 doesn't, 100 easily will.
Re:Battleships: a ridiculous but awesome idea
by stcredzero on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @12:02PM
(#2607878)
Yes, but if China also built the fleet, then it would be in a position to project power farther from its shores. If all you wanted to do is keep the carrier group away from your own shore, then capable missiles would suffice.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stealth_ship
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_212_submarine
A fleet of Sea Shadow type vessels and Air Independent Propulsion submarines combined with a good land-based air force would make life very difficult for carrier battle groups.