News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop defacing quotes with brackets by jusssi on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @03:35AM (#26075159)
But a quote intermingled with [paraphrase] just becomes a more awkward way to paraphrase? Because surely it isn't a verbatim quote any more.
Re:Stop defacing quotes with brackets by sokoloff on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @06:20AM (#26076191)
It’s a convenience to the reader. If I paraphrase a reference to support my point, it’s more work for you to determine if I’ve done so correctly. If I quote and update a dangling reference, it’s much easier for the reader to decide if I’ve done so in good faith and without introducing significant bias (whether intentionally or inadvertently).

I think it’s more faithful to the original, at a slight cost of fluid readability, which is often a good trade-off of features.

Re:Stop defacing quotes with brackets by ghusbands on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @06:21AM (#26076203)
You seem to be misunderstanding. Square brackets are not paraphrasing, they are correcting words for context. They should not alter the meaning, as paraphrasing often does.
Re:Stop defacing quotes with brackets by ddingus on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @03:50AM (#26075261)
Sure it is. The grammar is clear. One can know the quote exactly.

Frankly, implying otherwise diminishes the language.

Edit: All of which is why the article was written. People changing quotes, wrapping it in brackets so it flows better, in their view.

That's a mess!

Others here, myself included, correctly maintain appropriate bracket use does not change a quote, which is true until this garbage.