An example of a project I think would be less healthy under an umbrella would be LibreOffice. An example of a project I think would be more healthy under an umbrella would be the Haiku Operating System.
You largely cannot fight those big cheques, if you say "We don't want any corporate influence, go away", you lose, Amazon, Google and Microsoft do go away and build I dunno, "Titanium", a language eerily similar to Rust and with lots of manpower and money behind it.
You can put some structures in place to reduce the worst influences of money, you obviously don't want a situation where one day everybody senior at the Rust Foundation wouldn't know an IEEE float from a UTF-16 code unit and the language is allowed to decay and fail while executives fill their pockets from the dwindling coffers. But there are practical limits, at some point you must trust in the basic goodness of your fellow humans.
Our industry hasn't really been around long enough for the worst rot to set in, but there's a Vox story (I think?) years back about the problem of zombie foundations, with a set mission that ceased to make sense in the modern world. There's plenty of money but the intended charitable purpose no longer makes sense. A free primary school for the "disadvantaged" children in a long-since gentrified inner city region where the average child today is a millionaire is the sort of problem that arises.
https://github.com/rust-lang/foundation-faq-2020/blob/main/F...
As they are registering as a 501(c)6, I would assume that tax reasons would have impacting their decision not to join the SFC.
I find this attitude surprising. They are paying for development, why they shouldn't have authority to dictate the priorities? If it was SFC, some other interests would be dictating the priorities anyway.
If you are sponsoring a foundation and can dictate the direction you aren't a sponsor but an employer and owner. Then the foundation is just a way to make good looking PR or get tax-cuts.
Realistically, it all comes down to leverage and power. Who needs the other the most?
(For those not familiar, SFC is the home of Git, Godot Engine, Homebrew, Inkscape, QEMU, and Wine.)
My worry would be that this is happening because Amazon, Google, and Microsoft want control over the foundation. (They are writing the checks, so no surprise they'd want to control how that money gets invested…)