News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by ravi-delia on Monday February 08, 2021 @11:48AM (#26066915)
I'd definitely be surprised if a significant portion of homosexuality wasn't environmental, but to my knowledge there is a degree of heritability shown in twin studies. Actually reading the article shows that they found several genes that each contribute, but no single gene. That shouldn't be surprising to anyone, considering that almost every complex trait is somewhat affected by a huge number of genes each tweaking the result by a small amount. Remember that DNA controls the development of the body through an insanely complicated Rube Goldberg machine, no one should expect a 1:1 correspondence between any complicated trait and a gene.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by hajile on Monday February 08, 2021 @01:31PM (#26068234)
Identical twin studies point away from genetics very hard. Pretty much all genetic anomalies will affect both identical twins 100% of the time. The fact that it's less than 40% points much more to environmental effects rather than genes.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by drocer88 on Monday February 08, 2021 @04:57PM (#26070743)
From the link: "Research from the 1990s2 showed that identical twins are more likely to share a sexual orientation than are fraternal twins or adopted siblings."

Study here : https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9549243/

"We present an overview of behavioral genetics research on homosexual and heterosexual orientation. Family, twin, and adoptee studies indicate that homosexuality and thus heterosexuality run in families. "

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by jdgoesmarching on Monday February 08, 2021 @08:50PM (#26072883)
This thread seems very insistent on pushing the environmental case when presented with evidence to the contrary. It’s like I stumbled into a Republican convention in the 90s.

Baseless theories: people do this to feel better about LGBT discrimination or the idea of sexuality being out of our control is too scary for dudes who haven’t come to terms with their own masculinity. The latter isn’t necessarily shade, I’m not sure I figured it out until my mid-20s.

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by arp242 on Monday February 08, 2021 @10:44PM (#26073548)
You can believe that homosexuality is at least partly environmental while also believing that people should have the freedom to be as gay as they want to be.

I don't really like these appeals to motive; this is quite an interesting empirical question that's disconnected from discrimination. Even if it would turn out that homosexuality is a choice (I don't think it is, but let's assume it would be) then this wouldn't change my position one iota. People choose whether to smoke weed or not, and I also think people should have the freedom to choose to do so.

I'm not so sure what the evidence says on this, but it appears it's less of clear-cut "it's 100% genetic" than it seems to be. These things are notoriously hard to study.

The real problem seems to be that people are afraid that the "God hates fags" people will run with these kind of things, but these people will do their thing anyway no matter what the science says on account of being homophobic twats.

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by Neeek on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @02:04AM (#26074700)
I'm a little confused, you seem to be using choice and environment like they are synonymous here. It's a small nitpick but, even if this is environmental or epigenetic it doesn't necessarily mean that people get to choose the environment they exist in, at least in their formative years.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by arp242 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @09:06AM (#26089258)
Reading my post again, I probably could have chosen some better wording here and there. However, the point is that it doesn't matter if homosexuality is either environmental or a choice: the effects people having gay sex remains the same: people have gay sex with no negative consequences to anyone at all. Nothing more. And therefore they should have the freedom to have as much gay sex as they damn well please. Everything else is, quite frankly, just bullshit.

As I pointed out in my other comment[1], I definitely chose to have gay sex at some point and certainly could have chosen not to. I don't think it's so black/white.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26073364

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by Neeek on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @09:45PM (#26097662)
Of course! I should have mentioned that I absolutely agree with the thrust of your original comment :) I should have been less confrontational with my opening statement.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by supercheetah on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @05:25AM (#26075827)
That's not at all what was being said. The question of what causes homosexuality or heterosexuality is an interesting scientific question. Even if it were purely by choice, that doesn't reflect on any other characteristic of a person, and any fear that homophobes might try to use some hypothesis or another for their propaganda doesn't matter because they don't care about science anyway.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by hn_throwaway_99 on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @01:03AM (#26074378)
To be honest, as a gay man, I find the opposite is often true: that somehow insisting on homosexuality being genetically preordained is needed in order to argue against sexual-orientation-based discrimination. That is, if it is an inborn trait then gay people shouldn't be discriminated against because they "can't help it".

I've always found that somewhat offensive, because it somehow takes the sub/unconscious opinion that being gay is defective: "You wouldn't discriminate against someone with a severe birth defect, well gay people can't control it either." Fuck that. Whether it comes about from the genes, or through the environment, or most likely through some combination of the two, it is completely illogical for anyone who has ever felt sexual attraction of any kind to argue that it can "controlled", so I don't need some appeal to "it must be in my genes" to make me feel better.

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by MaxBarraclough on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @08:27AM (#26077178)
Also, there are already protected classes that are partly or wholly matters of choice. Religion, pregnancy, familial status, veteran status.

On a related note, I don't see that the is it a choice? question is even meaningful in the first place. Preferences aren't generally something we get to choose. I could probably learn to like some unfamiliar genre of music simply by listening to a lot of it, but you could offer me a heap of money to like the PHP programming language and I'd still be unable to do so. My opinion of it isn't something I can so easily will to change.

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by Itsdijital on Monday February 08, 2021 @09:22PM (#26073132)
It goes beyond that. The fear is that genetics will show that people are in fact not blank slates, and even further that there advantageous and disadvantageous traits common to groups of people.

I'm sure you can surmise the implications of this. Evolutionary biology has been making steady gains in the "nature not nurture" department and it has become an absolute lighting rod to discuss.

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by mehwoot on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @12:48AM (#26074314)
"environmental" doesn't mean it's a choice or that it can be effectively changed. For example environmental factors during pregnancy could have influence, but once someone is born it could be mostly determined. That would be entirely consistent with sexuality being somewhat genetic, mostly environmental, but unable to be changed after birth.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by coldtea on Monday February 08, 2021 @09:14PM (#26073078)
Hello, 1990 called. It's 2021, gender (including sexuality) is fluid.

And yet, it's the other commenters who seem backwards to you?

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by ravi-delia on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @12:36PM (#26080300)
I'm really not seeing anything in the above comment that indicates they don't see gender as fluid.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by coldtea on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @06:54PM (#26084162)
"pushing the environmental case when presented with evidence to the contrary"

Parent wants to push the "fixed gender" case instead.

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by monkeypizza on Monday February 08, 2021 @09:28PM (#26073180)
When the population base rate is low, and being genetically identical increases the rate to 40%, that is a strong argument that it's highly genetic. The effect only gets stronger to the extent the 40% is from environments where people would be reluctant to admit to homosexual experiences.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday February 08, 2021 @09:15PM (#26073086)
Is handed-ness environmental or is it genetic? It doesn't seem likely to be environmental...

21% of Monozygotic twins are left-handed when the other is right-handed. This is higher than the general population.

Aren't there plenty of genes that just lead to higher causes of something? There are identical albino and non-albino twins.

I'm really skeptical that albinism is environmental. But stranger things have happened, I suppose.

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by mr_overalls on Monday February 08, 2021 @04:32PM (#26070459)
A concordance rate of 40% actually points to a near-even split between heritable and non-heritable factors.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by ravi-delia on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @12:20PM (#26080101)
I'd say that that's probably more than a little bit of a simplification. Sexuality is almost certainly extremely polygenetic, interacting with the environment in all sorts of miserably complicated ways. Plus, the standard twin study design winds up counting pretty much all error as environmental.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by rootusrootus on Monday February 08, 2021 @08:52PM (#26072897)
My nephews are monozygotic twins. One is very straight, and the other is very gay. They happen to be mirror image twins. This points towards genetics.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by xvedejas on Monday February 08, 2021 @09:00PM (#26072962)
By "mirror image", do you mean very identical looking, or do they also have different handedness or something? I could go 50/50 on this being some term for twins I haven't heard before.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by rootusrootus on Monday February 08, 2021 @10:10PM (#26073406)
I mean mirror image twins. Approximately 25% of all identical twins are mirror image twins. Or mirror twins, or opposite twins. There are a few different terms for the same phenomenon. The exact cause is unknown but it's theorized that mirror image twins happen when the zygote splits a few days later than 'normal'.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by makeworld on Monday February 08, 2021 @11:45PM (#26073983)
This is an anecdote.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by anaphor on Monday February 08, 2021 @12:07PM (#26067176)
Remember that heritability is a measure of a population, not an individual. So you're measuring the amount that genes vs environment contributes to a trait within that population. It's not an absolute number.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by ravi-delia on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @12:30PM (#26080217)
I mean, yeah? It's still fairly strong evidence against there being literally no genetic component to homosexuality, which I definitely saw a lot of in this thread. Unless I misunderstand your comment?
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by anaphor on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:34AM (#26091321)
Not disagreeing with your original point, just adding that if you were controlling for environmental factors (everyone has equivalent environment), then you'd see more contribution to variance in phenotypes from genetics than environment. So for homosexuality, I'd bet the reason genetics don't contribute as much is because of the heterogeneous environmental conditions (just think about where you grow up and what religion you are for example).

Edit: a good example of this in action is handedness, because different societies historically have different advantages to using different hands

> Second, the samples used to estimate the handedness heritability were from different places, different years or different centuries and were not always representative of the general population. Heritability is not an intrinsic property of a trait: it varies with phenotypic and additive genetic variances and thus can vary across populations and across generations

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41437-019-0274-3

Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by ravi-delia on Thursday February 11, 2021 @01:39PM (#26105413)
Ahh got it, thanks for clarifying. That definitely makes sense, and clicks with my intuition that genetics and the environment are sort of both 100% responsible.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by unishark on Monday February 08, 2021 @05:22PM (#26071047)
The same goes for a cause we'd consider purely environmental, such as an illness caused by an infection. There will still be lots of associated genes with small effect determining how resilient a person is to the infection. Twins share environmental causes from early stages of development (like an infection during pregnancy) so that angle gets potentially confounded too.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by ravi-delia on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @12:25PM (#26080164)
Twin studies typically compare identical and fraternal twins to eliminate such environmental factors (Obviously there are still errors, but they generally wind up as counting towards environmental). And of course polygenetic factors probably have a sort of necessary-but-not-sufficient type of relationship with the traits they contribute too, but that doesn't mean that anything that isn't pegged to a single gene can be thought of as environmental.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by kabirgoel on Monday February 08, 2021 @05:43PM (#26071304)
Tangential to your point, but I enjoy the comparison you draw between DNA mechanisms and Rube Goldberg machines. It’s an apt metaphor because DNA, and the body as a whole, is constructed quite randomly according to the demands of the environment.
Re:The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuali... by ravi-delia on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @02:11PM (#26081355)
Oh absolutely! I can remember being so confused for so long about how DNA could possibly code for everything in an animal until I learned how convoluted and indirect the effect is. So much of what genes do is totally mediated by the process of development, emergent interactions between cells. No wonder we so rarely find clean correspondences between genes and traits, its honestly a miracle even polygenetic statistics find anything.