Re:Python’s tug of war between beginner-friendly and advance...
by ALittleLight on Thursday February 04, 2021 @08:59PM
(#26032189)
That is interesting. Trying your timeit code I've come to see that maybe something was wrong about how I was estimating the different performance. I was just using cProfile and profiling the two functions with big inputs and then comparing the cumulative time results that way. When I use your timeit examples my results (Intel Core i7-6700K CPU @ 4.00GHz) are different and closer to yours (pythonic ~1% slower). Thanks for sharing.
I personally think either function is fine. The max finding code pattern in the long function should be familiar to most. For the Pythonic function, I don't think it's less obvious enough to matter. You have a list of stuffs and you want to find the max so you wrap it in the max function. Maybe zip(xs, xs[1:]) can take a bit to recognize but I think it's eh. For the Pythonic one, one can also write
Using list is also markedly faster than the Pythonic generator for me, which is to be expected: ~16% faster than both.[0] https://gist.github.com/squaresmile/8dd08898851a4e19359cdb30...