Re:Bitcoins for Good
by abulafia on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:15PM
(#2603165)
This would be a significantly better project than bitcoin, and it would be possible, it just wouldn't serve the same purpose. What it would do is value time and effort; what it wouldn't do is waste pointless cycles and energy to make hidden currency. This currency would be valuable because someone put energy toward social good. In contrast, bitcoins are valuable because there's a limited quantity of them and their usage can be hidden. Hence, limitless "bitcoins for good" could be created, in a vibrant and dynamic economy, while highly deflationary bitcoins will simply sit in a miser's coffee can buried in the backyard.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by Jabbles on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:39PM
(#2603282)
Is bitcoin one of the most strenuous tests of the SHA-256 algorithm ever run? Besides the obvious benefit to the bitcoin ecosystem, this systematic hashing could provide useful data to a cryptographer. If there is ever a flaw in the algorithm discovered, I bet that bitcoin will play some part in it.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by jonprins on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @11:51AM
(#2603045)
The author is fundamentally flawed in his approach. He thinks bitcoin mining is just mindless churning on your GPU.
But in reality, it's cryptographically checking the validity of bitcoin transactions. So the system churns for the benefit of the system itself, instead of churning for the benefit of some external goal.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by eli on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:26PM
(#2603209)
No, I think everyone is on the same page. It's just semantics: mining is a mindless task, it just happens that bitcoin requires verifiable but otherwise pointless tasks in order to operate.
And I don't think you should dismiss this criticism so easily. I personally have very little confidence in bitcoin as a currency. But if the system also contributed to science by folding proteins or finding Mersenne primes or doing anything else that is externally useful, I would consider participating.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by jonprins on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:31PM
(#2603238)
Am I completely missing a key part of bitcoin, then? My understanding was the 'pointless tasks' were actually the verifications of previous transactions. And to make such a system verifiable, several nodes in the network must hash out the same blocks the same way.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by nhaehnle on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:54AM
(#2624290)
It depends on what you mean by verifying the transactions. Checking the signature of the transactions, to prove that the transaction was in fact issued by whoever owns the coins being sent, is only a negligible part of the computation.
The actual pointless task is to try to find a type of hash collision, to be specific: find a plaintext containing hashes of the transactions to be committed such that the hash of this plaintext starts with a bunch of zeroes. The more initial zeroes you require, the higher is the difficulty. (The plaintext is allowed to contain a small arbitrary nonce. So miners just cycle through all the possible nonces, computing hashes, until they find one that starts with a bunch of zeroes.)
It's conceivable that one could somehow mix the transaction data into a problem of bioinformatics, but I don't know so much about that. The problem is that, as far as I'm aware, some hash of the transactions to be committed must be part of the input of the "pointless" problem.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by eli on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:40PM
(#2603292)
Yes, that's my understanding. But it doesn't require that the tasks are "pointless" -- just that they are hard to compute, but relatively easy to verify.
There are lots of problems in bioinformatics and physics that are hard to compute and easily divided into chunks. Find one that also has easily verifiable results and you've got a pretty good candidate.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by wccrawford on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:18PM
(#2604024)
The 'pointless tasks' are the mining of the original coins. There are additional tasks for verifying the validity of the transactions of coins as well, but they take much less processing power.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by heyrhett on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @11:55AM
(#2603063)
This is not practical. If bitcoins related to some sort of market value for computation, there would be inflation of 40% / year.
Look at how mining for bitcoins compares to mining for real gold. Our species spends all this energy to dig gold up out of the ground, purify it, just to stick it back into the ground in vaults and then we pay someone to stand watching over it.
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by jdavid on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:52PM
(#2603342)
Actually the largest price driver of gold now is 'fear'.
Since many countries price their currencies to the USD, the USD has become a defacto currency. This means that inflationary pressure on the USD affects the whole world.
Gold prices are up as people are speculating that some countries will price their currency against gold. If countries don't do this, or if people stop believing that countries will do this, gold will go down in value.
Ironically large company stocks are probably the largest most stable and fluid currencies left. I think the term is fungible.
So if you buy stock in say a microsoft or a google, the changes are that those large company stocks will trade well if your home country's currency is inflating. The reason is that large companies diversify their holdings and optimize those holdings for profit. This is something that governments rarely do well.
I have started to wonder if investing in a sort of International Dow Jones as a currency base makes sense. I don't know how it would work, but it would be better than using gift cards as part of a currency as suggested by a few.
As for bitcoin as a currency, it seems to be based off of the cost of energy/ computing efficiency, however the currency does not seem to have been designed to match the USD, but rather make use of a set of tech features that were convenient to demonstrate it's proof.
It seems clear to me that Bit Coin Miner's will find the largest profits in using FPGA's, and that is unlikely to create a cloud structure that is useful for other things. How can you virtualize an FPGA?
Re:Bitcoins for Good
by abulafia on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:46PM
(#2603315)
There have been attempts to fix the value of gold for currency purposes, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Gold_Pool but these tend to simply prove the silliness of bothering with commodities when fiat currency is inherently more elegant and functional.
But in reality, it's cryptographically checking the validity of bitcoin transactions. So the system churns for the benefit of the system itself, instead of churning for the benefit of some external goal.
And I don't think you should dismiss this criticism so easily. I personally have very little confidence in bitcoin as a currency. But if the system also contributed to science by folding proteins or finding Mersenne primes or doing anything else that is externally useful, I would consider participating.
Protein folding is a probably better example. Or, I don't know, modeling long-term weather patterns?
Here's a list to start with: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_distributed_computing_p...
The actual pointless task is to try to find a type of hash collision, to be specific: find a plaintext containing hashes of the transactions to be committed such that the hash of this plaintext starts with a bunch of zeroes. The more initial zeroes you require, the higher is the difficulty. (The plaintext is allowed to contain a small arbitrary nonce. So miners just cycle through all the possible nonces, computing hashes, until they find one that starts with a bunch of zeroes.)
It's conceivable that one could somehow mix the transaction data into a problem of bioinformatics, but I don't know so much about that. The problem is that, as far as I'm aware, some hash of the transactions to be committed must be part of the input of the "pointless" problem.
There are lots of problems in bioinformatics and physics that are hard to compute and easily divided into chunks. Find one that also has easily verifiable results and you've got a pretty good candidate.
Look at how mining for bitcoins compares to mining for real gold. Our species spends all this energy to dig gold up out of the ground, purify it, just to stick it back into the ground in vaults and then we pay someone to stand watching over it.
And to state the obvious, not all gold goes in vaults. Both the supply and demand for gold is affected by its fashion and industrial uses.
Since many countries price their currencies to the USD, the USD has become a defacto currency. This means that inflationary pressure on the USD affects the whole world.
Gold prices are up as people are speculating that some countries will price their currency against gold. If countries don't do this, or if people stop believing that countries will do this, gold will go down in value.
Ironically large company stocks are probably the largest most stable and fluid currencies left. I think the term is fungible.
So if you buy stock in say a microsoft or a google, the changes are that those large company stocks will trade well if your home country's currency is inflating. The reason is that large companies diversify their holdings and optimize those holdings for profit. This is something that governments rarely do well.
I have started to wonder if investing in a sort of International Dow Jones as a currency base makes sense. I don't know how it would work, but it would be better than using gift cards as part of a currency as suggested by a few.
As for bitcoin as a currency, it seems to be based off of the cost of energy/ computing efficiency, however the currency does not seem to have been designed to match the USD, but rather make use of a set of tech features that were convenient to demonstrate it's proof.
It seems clear to me that Bit Coin Miner's will find the largest profits in using FPGA's, and that is unlikely to create a cloud structure that is useful for other things. How can you virtualize an FPGA?
All currencies are imperfect.