> The anti Huawei narrative is entirely political and not based on facts.
Are you saying that there are no security implications in having the CCP build and run your country's digital infrastructure?
Both Ericsson and Nokia barely make any profit, even amidst of what should be a 5G bonanza. They're famous for their perennial layoffs, constant cost-cutting, bland working conditions, outsourcing, infighting, insane level of bureaucracy and proliferation of management positions.
Huawei on the other hand, is well known for paying above-market wages (though long working hours), "poaching" skilled people from competitors, generous employee share scheme, valuing engineering above middle management, contributing to open source projects, and relative freedom their R&D personnel enjoys in tackling technical challenges. And their B2B offerings are the best value. And their consumer electronics is among the best value. And on top of that, they're highly profitable.
Even if you assert there's some secret money pump from CCP to Huawei, you cannot deny the fact that Huawei is a well-oiled machine that delivers. Pump billions into not only Nokia/Ericsson, but also IBM, SAP, HP, Oracle - the money would just get sucked into a black hole with very little to show for it. Huawei is portrayed as evil, because the alternative is to confront our weakness.
While this may be the case with some people with loose morals, don't put your words in my finger tips. I portray all major Chinese corps as the worst possible alternative in most cases because they are backed by a government with modern day concentration camps
I hang in the EU a lot lately. My friend takes corporate groups on tours of various places. She told me of one group from China last year who happened to see European reporting on protests in HK, while they were at a bar. The group's reaction was "what is this a joke? Are they being sarcastic? Is this a movie?" They had no idea what was happening in HK. A couple of them sent messages home to friends/family about the matter and within minutes all of their phones were disabled.
This actually happened. I want that government as far from me as possible.
There was wide National Support for the crackdown on HK protests, it wasn't controversial at all. The government didn't need to censor any of the media.
> I portray all major Chinese corps as the worst possible alternative in most cases because they are backed by a government with modern day concentration camps
So half of Europe and South America have modern day concentration camps, they just call them "Refugee Camps". In other Asia Pacific Countries (including Australia) they have "Immigration Detention Centres" (prisons for the persecuted). In the US they have Gitmo AND immigration detention.
In China they have Work Camps and Re-eduction camps.
I fail to see the moral high ground. Are you from a part of the world I missed?
OK, I give up being reasonable. Collect your 50 cents.
> I fail to see the moral high ground. Are you from a part of the world I missed?
I am not claiming any moral high ground. In fact, my experience tells me that anyone claiming the moral high ground for one country/race/group over another takes the risk of being a dangerous fool. This side of humanity will be our end if we do not grow out of it very soon.
Huawei is a legitimate threat from a country that doesn't have the same checks and balances as other countries e.g. free media, robust judiciary, democracy.
And it's not like network providers are specifically trying to secure their platform against Huawei. It's against anyone.
It doesn't matter if you're dealing with a dictatorship or a democracy when it comes to foreign policy. Both will kill you.
I take exception to this as I have been trying to explain to everyone how evil the CCP is for many years. It is not recent. Using the term CCP is simply an attempt to accurately identify the problem, and not be lazy/racist by blaming things on "China."
Also, Hua wei isn’t the ccp. I’m sure there is influence for sure. Just like there is influence in US companies from government.
The lowest common denominator for systems which I find "evil" are systems with low accountability.
Non-democratic authoritarian regimes, populations with large income divides, US policing systems, economies with monopolistic actors... all of these things are systems with low-to-zero accountability.
Or if you are truly asking the innocent question "how are they evil?" Examples of how the CCP is evil can be found in HK jails, Tianamen square, and Xinjiang province for a start.
I agree democracy helps distribute power... I don’t agree it makes people more accountable. Or is inherently less/more “evil”.
Compare China and US Covid response. Which one has held people more accountable, which one has been more evil?
Also, just because I am currently talking about the evils of the CCP does not spare other actors and systems from my derision.
People seem to be easily led down the path of A vs B when the truth is always more complex. For example, the antique dichotomy of Capitalism vs Socialism is somehow still the main discussion. From my POV, history has clearly proven both doctrines as faulty in their pure forms. For years we have seen and lived the "third way" but somehow, it's still Capitalism vs Socialism in the conversation.
The reaction to COVID clearly shows how plain dumb US capitalism really is. That doesn't excuse the CCP from anything.
I hope somewhere on the Chinese version of HN there is someone saying “hey let’s stop gratuitously hating on the US”
In comment threads about China, yes. But also, you keep twisting my words. I never said China bad, I said CCP truly evil.
> I hope somewhere on the Chinese version of HN...
This is either disingenuous or very naïve. Please send me a link to a Chinese platform for open discourse where their own government can be criticized, like I criticize the US government in this thread, and I will donate $500 to the charity of your choice.
This thread is about Huawei a Chinese company. Not the CCP... am I the one twisting words? Or does everything Chinese immediately get grouped up to CCP and hated on?
I know an informed opinion of China when I see people make a distinction between Xi, CCP, and Chinese companies... they are not the same thing at all.
Actually, the CCP controls all companies in China, and has agents on site in each company over about 40 employees. The founder is PLA, which reports to the CCP.
Larger companies often have to have a ccp representative, these aren’t agents... Founders are not PLA... you mean Huawei in particular... the founder was once in the army?
Larger companies must have a CCP cell in the company. Whether you call them reps or agents, they're CCP.
> Founders are not PLA... you mean Huawei in particular... the founder was once in the army?
The Huawei founder was a member of the PLA, and likely still is, since generally ex-military can always be recalled.
Technology companies in China are dual-use (both civilian and military).
Or how Johnson and Johnson’s CEO is Ex military? Guess you should think twice about that shampoo.
And that CCP cell controls the direction of the company? Or less dramatically does it ensure (a) workers rights (admittedly these are far worse conditions than western countries), and (b) that the company isn’t working against the CCP.
Many people have issues with Israel's foreign policy for example but that doesn't mean they are anti-semitic or anyway blame the Israeli people.
No, they blame "Israel", which is a political and national entity. You can be more specific and blame one leader or party when that is a variable, but that's not the case with China- the CCP is in fact its fundamental political organisation.
So the only reason to talk of "the CCP" instead of "China" is that it reframes an issue which is mostly a struggle for economic and military power between countries, to an issue within China itself, between the Chinese people and their government. Which is dishonest, because truth is, from one side the Chinese don't have much issues with their government, it's working great for them; and from the other side, the US would have issue with any government of China, as long as it keeps steadily advancing to become the first economic power in the world. But of course admitting that is not easy, so it's better to pretend the issue is "the CCP".