News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlig... by blunte on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:29PM (#26016234)
This will always be a cat and mouse game, although you would think Apple could have done better here.

Perhaps a more effective solution would be for Apple to aggressively legally pursue bad actors like the group that churns out these apps. Make them hurt financially as an example to the next people who might entertain similar ideas.

If Apple doesn’t start handling this better, eventually there will only be bad/fake apps on the store. Real developers will widely choose not to play the losing game.

Re:Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlig... by cwyers on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:25PM (#26017149)
I'm sure that app review is a hard problem. But it seems like Apple has the worst of both worlds sometimes -- HN frequently puts cases where an existing, very successful app gets suddenly dinged for something, or a new app from a big vendor gets nailed on a point of policy. Meanwhile absolute shovelware like this seems to be able to clear the review process no problem.
Re:Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlig... by zepto on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:56PM (#26017574)
Those big cases where an existing app gets dinged are often justified, but are also extremely rare.

Keeping out shovelware while also allowing rudimentary but useful apps by new developers is a much harder problem.

They aren’t really connected in any particular way.

Re:Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlig... by ncf04212 on Thursday February 04, 2021 @08:01AM (#26024952)
> Those big cases where an existing app gets dinged are often justified, but are also extremely rare.

There have been many cases ( like Hey ) where Apple justification for removing apps was "We saw you're making money, therefore give us money, even tho we provide zero added value".

Re:Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlig... by zepto on Thursday February 04, 2021 @11:34AM (#26026910)
"We saw you're making money, therefore give us money, even tho we provide zero added value.”

This is just something you made up.

Apple’s justification was quite different.

Re:Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlig... by elliekelly on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:13PM (#26016959)
> Perhaps a more effective solution would be for Apple to aggressively legally pursue bad actors like the group that churns out these apps. Make them hurt financially as an example to the next people who might entertain similar ideas.

Maybe a year or so ago Amazon started to aggressively pursue legal action against a few people who were abusing their return process. People who were clearly and egregiously stealing millions of dollars from Amazon via fraudulent returns. I haven’t seen any follow-up reporting but I would love to know the numbers behind the cost/benefit. It doesn’t seem to have had any impact on customer experience and I have to imagine there were others similarly abusing the process who have since stopped. I suspect the approach has largely paid off.