Each to their own, I suppose.
I mail a _lot_ of copy-pasta from shell output, so not having to switch to plaintext manually saves time. To be honest the sort of mail that's multicoloured / multifont / etc. generally isn't worth reading, let alone replying to; but that's just my experience.
Auto-switching email like that to plain text makes it difficult to read, screws up the layout, and loses information entirely.