News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: GPL software works but what are the cons? by mindcrime on Monday May 30, 2011 @07:26PM (#2600725)
You haven't really given us enough information to answer your question. In fact, I suspect you haven't yet asked the question(s) you really want/need to ask. I think you need to spend some time getting familiar with the top most popular F/OSS licenses, and the implications of each of them. There's a really good book on that very topic titled Understanding Open Source and Free Software Licensing. I recommend you read it for a good introduction:

http://oreilly.com/catalog/osfreesoft/book/

For example, is building a social network or designing a template using a GPL software package a bad business plan?

Using, or not using, F/OSS isn't a business plan, it's just a detail - one element of many in a business model/plan. Whether or not it's a bad idea would depend on the other elements of said model. That said, Red Hat and others have proven the validity of selling F/OSS, if that's what you're getting at.

Re:Ask HN: GPL software works but what are the cons? by starter on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:04PM (#2603105)
Thanks for laying it out like that. Yes, its a detail but I think its a very important detail don't you think?
Re:Ask HN: GPL software works but what are the cons? by mindcrime on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:52PM (#2604181)
Sure, most likely it is important - but without knowing more about the intended scenario, it's really hard to say. In the case of a social network, if one were to make a site which is strictly hosted, and never distributes their code, then one could use GPL'd code to your hearts content with basically no ramifications. But decide to sell the product for use on-site, and now it's a whole different game. Or pull in AGPL'd code versus GPL'd code and it changes the game. Hence my previous reference to the F/OSS licensing book. Understanding all these licenses and how they interact and what their implications are, is pretty important for anybody going down this path.
Re:Ask HN: GPL software works but what are the cons? by starter on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @11:08AM (#2607586)
Yes, well, I'll at least have enough foresight to avoid AGPL or similar code if possible. Its just a good thing to understand what I may encounter once I've invested a year and a million dollars into something which might have unwanted public rights.