News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Knol is Evil by nickb on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @12:02AM (#260018)
I don't understand the argument. It's Microsoft's operating system, if they want to pre-install certain apps, why not?

Google's heading in the same direction as MS. They'll probably end up in the same court room in Washington DC few years from now.

Re:Google Knol is Evil by neilc on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @01:26AM (#260121)
It's Microsoft's operating system, if they want to pre-install certain apps, why not?

There's nothing fundamentally wrong with Microsoft pre-installing apps, just like there is nothing wrong with Apple pre-installing apps on OSX, or Sun on Solaris.

Re:Google Knol is Evil by agotterer on Wednesday July 30, 2008 @01:01AM (#261535)
but it is wrong that Apple forces safari downloads on windows! grrr!
Re:Google Knol is Evil by vaksel on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @01:51AM (#260147)
if it wasn't, they wouldn't have lost all those anti-trust suits
Re:Google Knol is Evil by akd on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @01:58AM (#260158)
The courts do not always assess right and wrong -- they are concerned with legal and illegal, which isn't the same thing.
Re:Google Knol is Evil by aditya on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @03:01PM (#260947)
That comparison does not work. Microsoft pre-installing their applications, or tweaking their OS such that their applications provide a better experience is anti-competitive because it lets Microsoft utilize their monopoly to prevent competition.

Google is not preventing any other search engines from gaining popularity. People go to google to find the most relevant answer to a particular thing, when the top result is consistently a spam knol, people won't go there to search anymore.

Re:Google Knol is Evil by alex_c on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @04:29PM (#261046)
You're getting the two mixed up.

The concern with Microsoft wasn't that they used their OS monopoly to unfairly compete with other operating systems, it was that they used their OS monopoly to unfairly compete with other applications (eg. IE vs. Netscape).

The concern with Google isn't that they might be using their search near-monopoly to unfairly compete with other search engines, it is that they might be using their search near-monopoly to unfairly compete with other websites (eg. Knol vs. Wikipedia).