News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS ... by anigbrowl on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:56PM (#25985690)
It's great but until someone comes up with something better than 'solder on a screen, 3d print a case' it's going nowhere for lack of critical mass. The best thing that could happen to this is if it turned from a $35 project into a $50 product. I know a bunch of people who find it interesting and would be into investing in deployment (as backup comms for natural disaster scenarios), but nobody wants to commit to soldering 50 of these things.
Re:Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS ... by boschetto on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @06:12AM (#25999633)
I am considering it.

From a quick calculation (micro-production, 1 man operation, 50 units batch):

- Materials: considering the best supported module (T-Beam V1.1 w/ NEO-M8N /w SX1262) with an OLED screen, an upgrade to a decent GPS antenna (ceramic, 28mm^2), 3D printed case and 2 Panasonic 18650.

Materials cost: 48€/piece.

- Assembly: pipelining would probably be bottlenecked by display soldering (outsourcing the 3D printing). Batching soldering could bring that down to ~1 min/piece. Flashing/testing can be fully automated and parallelized with soldering. Final assembly should be an additional 30s/piece. Start up ~10min considering testing machine boot and soldering iron warm up.

Assembly time: 85 min/batch --> <2 min/unit

Assembly cost (50€/hour): 71 €/batch -> 1.42 €/unit

Shipping (EU): 10€

Support cost: can't estimate well, let's say 1€/unit

Defective cost (10%): 13€/unit (2 procuct units, 3 shippings)

Cost per unit: 73€

Retail price (40% margin): 102€

It's viable but pretty expensive (a lot more than 50$). For sure more expensive than a goTenna Mesh and offering less support.

I won't make money from it but it could be a good learning opportunity.

edit: formatting

Re:Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS ... by dopidopHN on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @10:21PM (#26010223)
I would buy one, as well as few naked one that I would solder myself. Those things could become very nifty. Solving problems that mesh-wifi can't quiet get right for organic deployment.
Re:Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS ... by snops on Monday February 01, 2021 @04:02AM (#25986907)
There is hardware available with the same microcontroller (ESP32) in a thick watch style case, but I don't know if anyone has ported meshtastic to it yet. On the face of it, power usage looks a bit higher due to the LCD display rather than OLED.

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/10000161655843.html

Re:Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS ... by anigbrowl on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:50PM (#25992826)
Intriguing. Power consumption might not be as big a problem on a portable device.
Re:Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS ... by dopidopHN on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @10:22PM (#26010236)
Han, that's fun.
Re:Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS ... by bordercases on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:01AM (#25986019)
How long would it take per unit?
Re:Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS ... by anigbrowl on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:18AM (#25986121)
Not very, but the point is that the necessity to set up an assembly line is a sticking point for adoption. You need to deploy a lot of these to make it useful so skill or time bottlenecks are a big disincentive.