Re:Cory Doctorow: IP (2020)
by bawolff on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:04AM
(#25976155)
Well i agree generally, the parent did not make reference to the scarcity of physical property.
I agree with him/her that the enforcement aspect is just an extension of the enforcement rights of regular property. Where i disagree is that intellectual ideas should be owned like physical things in the first place, with the difference being scarcity as you say. Maybe im being pedantic but i feel like its an important distinction to make.
Re:Cory Doctorow: IP (2020)
by dnautics on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:35AM
(#25976336)
Just fyi- I think you mean rivalrousness, not scarcity, they're not exactly the same, and edge cases where they are similar but one is mistreated as the other have historically had serious consequences.
I agree with him/her that the enforcement aspect is just an extension of the enforcement rights of regular property. Where i disagree is that intellectual ideas should be owned like physical things in the first place, with the difference being scarcity as you say. Maybe im being pedantic but i feel like its an important distinction to make.