News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by phkahler on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:59PM (#25975034)
Narcissism. "I've read many books and governmental reports..." is (presumably) a fact. It's a fact about the person saying it and not about the issue. It's a way to claim "I know what I'm talking about" without evidence.

Unfortunately in today's world, you can be well read in any subject and still end up on either side based on what you've read.

Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by Udik on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:12PM (#25975109)
> It's a fact about the person saying it

Which ironically enough, seems to be the definition itself of "personal experience".

Notice also how there is emotion thrown in: "it made me feel strongly about". How is this supposed to be an argument?

Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by xnyan on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:02PM (#25975780)
> How is this supposed to be an argument?

I agree, if heard that kind of argument then I would think it was ridiculous and narcissistic.

My personal experience is that people often argue in this way, and if I’m being honest if I don’t catch myself than I too am tempted to argue this way.

I think there’s a few factors going on, foremost perhaps an aspect of normal human psychology is that when humans process information and from that information come to a observation or conclusion, we tend to remember the conclusion we came to and not the process of coming to that conclusion. Also, I know that I personally (and also everyone else too I believe) think about myself quite a bit more than anyone else. It’s easy to live in my head and forget that not everyone knows what think I know.

So tldr - forgetting stuff and being selfish

Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by patcon on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:15AM (#25979827)
Do they not control for "trust" that the person has genuine factual knowledge? So your personal doubting due to lack of sources is controlled for, I believe, in their "manipulation checks" on page 1.

So people who aren't presented with enough cues to create trust (and even the strongest rationalist has their own thresholds here, e.g. your heart surgeon, a Nobel laureate, etc) would be factored into account. Citation only matters to the listener when trust doesn't exist, esp when "determinations of truthfulness in the universe" isn't even what the researchers care to study -- but rather, how respect develops between the people who receive trusted facts vs trusted experiences :)