News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by forkandwait on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:01PM (#2597240)
When we finally design a simulated brain, I wonder if (1) it will be really good at spatial and behavioral behavior (balancing, motor skills, quick non-explicit decision making etc), but really bad at doing math?

Not to say we shouldn't keep trying, but we all seem to think that the best computer will evolve from solving lots and lots of partial differential equations into being like the brain, but animal brains have evolved to solve really different questions than why we have been making computers.

Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by shantanubala on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:13PM (#2597284)
Not to mention neuroplasticity: the brain literally can reallocate neurons to different functions based on whether they're used (and what functions are needed). It's a really fascinating aspect of psychological therapy and rehabilitation for people with birth defects or traumatic brain injuries. If a person has a damaged or missing part of their brain, they can develop the same functionality elsewhere. The brain is built to adapt to information instead of just processing information.

EDIT: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroplasticity

Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by bermanoid on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:49PM (#2597394)
Not to say we shouldn't keep trying, but we all seem to think that the best computer will evolve from solving lots and lots of partial differential equations into being like the brain, but animal brains have evolved to solve really different questions than why we have been making computers.

The thing that always strikes me as interesting about the evolution of intelligence is that it's a mostly unnecessary latecomer to the evolutionary party: plenty of things thrive in nature without anything even remotely resembling human intelligence, even plenty of large animals that function quite well in complex environments rely mostly on hard coded "unintelligent" systems in their brains.

The fact is, most of the problems that need to be solved to survive and reproduce can be solved very effectively without much general intelligence. Sure, once evolution discovers intelligence it turns out to be a very efficient way to implement a lot of functionality that would otherwise need to be hard coded, but it's not strictly necessary, and nature did just fine without it for a long time.

The good news: that also means that it's unlikely that significant evolutionary pressures went into designing the complex systems responsible for intelligent thought, so they were probably accidentally "designed" via random drift. If you think about that, given the complexity of the algorithms involved, it means that the algorithm space at that level complexity is probably fairly dense with algorithms that function intelligently (where by "fairly dense" I mean that it's a lot denser than we might assume otherwise, and the solution that evolution came up with is probably not the only possible one).

That means if we ever figure out how to do a guided search through algorithms of the right complexity in the right way, we may yet stand a chance of "accidentally" discovering intelligence rather than deliberately designing it.

Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by Peaker on Sunday May 29, 2011 @05:12PM (#2597607)
> that also means that it's unlikely that significant evolutionary pressures went into designing the complex systems responsible for intelligent thought, so they were probably accidentally "designed" via random drift

I find this unlikely. Perhaps the initial "push" towards intelligence was based in random drift, but humans' evolutionary path has actually paid quite a dear price to have the high intelligence that we have:

* Larger brains led to larger heads

* Larger heads led to the need to give birth earlier, and with more risk

* Earlier birth lead to helpless babies

* Helpless babies require much more care, and mothers become dependent on fathers

* Large brains are only very useful if trained for long periods of time leading to long, expensive and dangerous childhoods

I don't think this whole process can be explained by random drift.

I think the question of what caused pressure towards higher intelligence in our evolutionary process can be answered by competition.

Analogously, consider tree heights. A tree doesn't need to be very high at all to collect sunlight. But a tree competing with other trees can grow to tremendous heights due to competition.

When competing for resources with other similarly intelligent beings, more intelligence could definitely yield an evolutionary edge.

Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by sliverstorm on Sunday May 29, 2011 @04:55PM (#2597579)
Of course it's not neccesary. It's no more neccesary than being multicellular.
Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by ignifero on Sunday May 29, 2011 @09:17PM (#2598091)
The main differentiating factor that turns humans to thinkers is language. There are very few other species who have some form of communications and none have the capacity to express complex abstract syntactic structures like we do. It has obvious evolutionary benefits, and as a side effect it gives us the ability to reflect on the world. There are other faculties that we miss, that might also have interesting side effects (e.g. magnetoreception), but based on the size of the achievements of the human race, language is more important.
Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by 27182818284 on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:31PM (#2597332)
On Intelligence is a good, novice introduction to the brain, its parts like the neocortex, and how studying the brain can help us design better artificial brains.

One point the book made that I thought was very insightful was that once we understand brains well enough to make artificial ones, we can pick and choose features like a little bit of Einstein mixed with a little bit of Zuckerberg's brain.

Anyway, if you have some spare time, check it out. It is a short book and I learned a few things.

Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by dkersten on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:47PM (#2597386)
Thats ok, we can then connect a more traditional coprocessor to offload the math heavy work to (perhaps some kind of SIMD stream processor).
Re:The brain's 5-million core, 9 Hz computer by ignifero on Sunday May 29, 2011 @09:06PM (#2598063)
The assumption is that in the process we will have discovered new insights in the high-level functions of the brain that are not apparent in our current-level AI. We should then be able to figure out how to make it "better" at math or motor skills.