The media and the government routinely mislead the public, look at in 2019 the intentional confusion of blackmarket thc vapes and tobacco vaping. Or more recently, the use of human trafficking.
To claim there was sometime in the past where the news was good and reliable would require overlooking a huge amount of actual historic malfeasance.
1) a media outlet that repeats government lies about why we are fighting a war (or how it is going)
2) a media outlet that ignorantly repeats mistruths that are present in the (sub)culture
3) a media outlet that makes up its own lies
We used to mostly have a mixture of 1 & 2, but we now have to contend with (3) as well.Found out a decade later that story never happened, and it was a big enough deal for it to be in the list of urban legends and a controversy of how the news decided to report it at the time.
We have been dealing with (3) for a very long time. We dont even know what’s polluted our minds as truth.
Reality almost never matches with your worst fears, reality is typically different and strange. You should be very skeptical if it matched your worst fears no matter what the source.
The satanic ritual abuse stuff was in the 80s early 90s. Lies that led to vietnam, sure. But also there were lies that led to the Iraq war in the more fractured Fox News/internet age so it seems like the more fractured, politicized news didn't help protect against that.
> To claim there was sometime in the past where the news was good and reliable would require overlooking a huge amount of actual historic malfeasance.
Sure, my point was there was a past where we had a more common narrative. That certainly has downsides, but now we're seeing that it had some advantages compared to our current fractured era.
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/emma-goldman-the-whi...
The significance of that varies by person. If you need social reinforcement to validate your interpretation of information the media lying is certainly significant, but then if you are more reliant upon social reinforcement you aren't acting on original interpretations of the information anyways. In other words this argument is moot.
This upsets the 10% very much.
You can see the natural progression towards hyper bifurcated viewpoints.
It's continuing to trend downward, so "going to nothing" is not a clearly false summary, but we might as well be specific
Source: https://www.statista.com/chart/20244/estimated-print-adverti...
A paper supported by the big department store's ads is incentivised to be broad, because the store wants to sell to everyone. Likewise a paper supported classified and by sunday realtor adds -- nobody wants to sell their house exclusively to members of some fringe, they want the widest distribution.
But a paper supported by its most outraged subscribers will cater to them, and importantly, to keeping them outraged.
People don't need to pay for news, so they generally won't.
The smaller publications are all getting wiped out, NYT and a few others will remain paywalled in a smaller state of affairs, and that's it.
https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/65213-briefly-stated-the-ge...
What Mass Media calls facts are more often wrong than right, even without any political bias. When political bias are factored in, so called "facts" are complete opposite of what they are.
"The problem is that facts—at least today—are themselves subject to doubt, especially when they conflict with our political beliefs (21). In the past decades, America has seen a decentralization of news and information (22) that has allowed people to gather their “own facts” (i.e., alternative facts; ref. 23). Most recently, claims of “fake news” allow people to distrust any information that fails to align with their political beliefs (24, 25) and to trust fake news that aligns with their beliefs (26)."
This is the epistemic crisis we're currently facing. Up until about the late 70s we had 3 news networks that were all pretty much middle of the road politically. Newspapers could have more of a discernible political leaning, but even there most of the mainstream ones we're pretty centrist. People who hewed to an extreme political position in either direction were ostracized and thus had a very small audience. We had more of a common narrative which is now gone.