News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by terse_malvolio on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:44PM (#25965504)
Except when you look at videos of the world record level typists, they don't always type with 'proper' technique.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by colanderman on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:24PM (#25966027)
I am a self-taught typist from a young age. I type very fast (140 WPM? I forget) but my technique is totally non standard. I hold my hands/wrists at "natural" angles (as one would on a split keyboard), but on a standard keyboard. No "home row" for me. The letters in the middle of the keyboard are liable to be typed by either hand, depending on the word: I cannot use a split keyboard because of this. Thumb helps out with lower row sometimes. I can type single-handedly without much difficulty.

I credit this "technique" with not having developed any sort of keyboard-related RSI over 30 years of daily typing. Mice gave me terrible grip-related RSI after a decade (I now use a trackball), but not so with typing.

I assume I'm not unique in having stumbled naturally on this method. But it's not something I've ever seen taught, probably because it's not very "orderly".

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by userbinator on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:48PM (#25966197)
I'm pretty much the same as you --- the best description of my method would be "closest available finger". I can type at ~150WPM for long periods of time without any strain or tiredness, can reach 200+ in short bursts, and have done over 50WPM with only the left hand.

However, one thing I've found that really affects typing speed and comfort is the key travel and actuation force; I think a "light, spongy, bouncy" feel is best. A light force reduces strain, sponginess is a good cushion, and the bounce helps speed up the return stroke. You can type a lot faster once you train yourself to not try to await any tactile feedback, but just "trust" that you've hit the keys and they've actuated.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by IggleSniggle on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:08AM (#25969644)
I am the same way. I always attributed it to early experiences learning to play the piano. The muscle memory is in your whole arm/hand/finger about the location, and the sequence of fingers is dependent on the sequence of keys that follow.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by colanderman on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:27PM (#25971505)
Yep, I also learned to play piano around the same time I learned to type. They're very similar to me.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by colanderman on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:26PM (#25971495)
Agreed re: key feel. I learned on an Apple //e and still think that's ideal. MacBook keyboards are the worst for me... the constant tactile feedback I think creates a negative feedback response that overtrains my fingers, leading to weird typing mistakes. Switching back to a mechanical keyboard helped.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by atoav on Saturday January 30, 2021 @03:45AM (#25967421)
Thats why I like Cherry MX black switches (heavy accentuation force, linear without click). You can basically tap them very lightly and type without bottoming out.

I am a bass player, so my finger muscles are very strong and I a little more resistance others may prefer red or silver switches.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by dataflow on Saturday January 30, 2021 @03:32AM (#25967378)
How in the world do you type 50WPM with just the left hand? Do you practice the right hand side of the keyboard with your left hand?
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by atoav on Saturday January 30, 2021 @03:47AM (#25967426)
If you play the piano or guitar you and you are used to use the left hand in such a way, I suspect it is totally doable.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by colanderman on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:30PM (#25971534)
For me it's just like... my brain knows where the keys are, and my fingers know how to move to where they're needed. I do have to look when typing one-handed, but it's more to help "aim" that to search for where the keys are.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by Stratoscope on Saturday January 30, 2021 @06:13AM (#25968163)
Keeping your wrists at a natural angle is very helpful for avoiding RSI and carpal tunnel injuries. I've been typing for 60 years and have never had these problems.

A while ago I posted some bad ASCII art of what we're talking about here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20663540

The parent thread also has some good tips.

I do use the standard touch typing finger/key assignments, I just don't bend my wrists doing it.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by rrauenza on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:03AM (#25966300)
I have the opposite problem. I started with hunt and peck as a kid and never learned a proper technique. I believe that caused me more problems...

Switching to proper touch typing was really hard because my adhoc method is so much faster... Until I become proficient.

During quarantine I acquired a kinesis which was interesting - typing "incorrectly" on it is difficult! It took me about a week or two to touch type on it without frustration ...and I find my hands have less rsi from it.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by colanderman on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:32PM (#25971558)
I was exposed to typing lessons, which helped give me the idea that using all fingers and memorizing where keys are is important. I sort of stopped halfway and ran with it I guess.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by klyrs on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:41PM (#25966140)
Interesting. I hold my left hand roughly on the home row, but like you, my right hand is at an odd angle. As a programmer, this seems very natural to me because I have rapid access to the brackets, parens, etc. without stretching my pinky. Coincidentally, I use a trackball too.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by desmap on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:53AM (#25966900)
Would love to see a video of your typing style/you typing eg at monkeytype
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by colanderman on Sunday January 31, 2021 @02:00AM (#25976742)
Sorry for the terrible angle. The phone is hanging off my jacket. But this gives a good view of how my fingers share duty in the center of the keyboard: https://youtu.be/YH0YFJEcy0c

Apparently I misremembered my speed... Monkeytype tells me I average ~110 WPM. With one hand I get ~45 WPM.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by desmap on Monday February 01, 2021 @06:41AM (#25987787)
Nice that you did this video and still a very nice speed. Every test is different re difficulty, so all good.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by colanderman on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:51PM (#25971786)
If I can figure out how to aim a camera at my keyboard I'll try to do so later today.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by Arainach on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:14PM (#25965667)
Sprinting and marathon running have very different technique. Life (and a career involving computers) is a marathon, and that's what ergonomics is about.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by kkoncevicius on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:15AM (#25970243)
The idea that the "proper" touch typing technique is ergonomic is not unquestionable. I've read some forums about RSI and there were quite a few people stating they got RSI right at the time they started learning and using the proper touch-typing method.

It makes sense too. Without formal training your hands will assume comfortable positions on the keyboard and the writing technique will evolve to suit your hand size and your movements. This should be more ergonomic compared to strict rules, developed for type-writers, where you have to press each key with the same finger every time, and where typical programming keys (brackets, colons) are left to the smallest finger.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by Arainach on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:22PM (#25971462)
What is comfortable initially is not guaranteed (or even likely) to be repeatable thousands of times. Look at weight lifting - if you ask an untrained person to lift a barbell or heavy bag the way that "feels natural", they'll probably lift with their back or do something else that would cause major problems if done repeatedly over the long term.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by logbiscuitswave on Saturday January 30, 2021 @02:21AM (#25967045)
Right? I don’t really use all my fingers most of the time. It’s pretty unorthodox. I can easily get 120+ WPM with pretty good correctness. I’m self taught so I just picked up something that worked for me at a young age and ran with it. I can be insecure about it sometimes but since it works well enough for me I haven’t had much motivation to “fix” it.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by kemitchell on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:10PM (#25965641)
I noticed fairly recently that I often, but not always, type the letter "P" with my ring finger, rather than my little (pinky) finger. I'm still not sure whether that's adaptive or wrong.

Have you seen good resources on high-speed typing technique?

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by MaxLeiter on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:18PM (#25965679)
Get an ergonomic (probably split) keyboard and use your thumb for modifier keys. It’s meant to rotate all around unlike our pinkies.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by thom on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:09AM (#25968435)
I’ve been using a couple of split keyboards over the last year and it’s slowed me down because I can no longer cross over the keyboard to type a letter with either hand. This means you sometimes have to use the same finger twice in a row which always feels inefficient to me.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by desmap on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:56AM (#25966917)
It's wrong but the p is on a very hard position for the right pinky. FWIW, p was the last letter I got right as a touch typist. It's not that the pinky is a weak finger--it can be trained to a very good level--it's really more the position of the p.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by thom on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:10AM (#25968441)
I’ve just moved p down a row on most of my keyboards.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by fireattack on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:34PM (#25966093)
I'm similar but worse, I basically type all the upper row with ring and middle finger only.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by colanderman on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:31PM (#25966076)
I don't think I use the pinky for any letter, only Enter and modifiers. Pinkies are weak.

If you allow your forearm to move, rather than keeping your fingers in a "home" position, you do not need to use pinkies to reach letters.