I'm not sure. You might be right. However section 5.4 also says:
If AstraZeneca is unable to deliver on its intention to manufacture the Initial Europe Doses and/or Optional Doses under this Agreement in the EU, the Commission or the Participating Member States may present to AstraZeneca, CMOs within the EU capable of manufacturing the Vaccine Doses, and AstraZeneca shall use its Best Reasonable Efforts to contract with such proposed CMOs to increase the available manufacturing capacity within the EU.
"Within the EU" in this particular paragraph encompasses the UK, so my reading of this is that if AstraZeneca can't deliver the Initial Europe Doses as it plans, the Commission can propose alternative manufacturing sites that include UK sites. Which seems to cover the Comission's current request that AstraZeneca use UK-made doses to honour its commitment to deliver the Initial Europe Doses (to its best reasonable efforts etc).
Again, IANAL, so I don't know how to interpret this document correctly. I'm reading it as a lay person who does not understand the technicalities of legal terminology.
> "Within the EU" in this particular paragraph encompasses
> the UK, so my reading of this is that if AstraZeneca
> can't deliver the Initial Europe Doses as it plans,
> the Commission can propose alternative manufacturing
> sites that include UK sites. Which seems to cover the
> Commission's current request that AstraZeneca use UK-made
> doses to honour its commitment to deliver the
> Initial Europe Doses (to its best reasonable efforts etc).
Yeah, I understand this mostly the same way, but my read is that while they can make such a request, AstraZeneca can choose not to do this and isn't forced into taking away vaccines from one country contractually as part of "best reasonable efforts".IANAL also, but I have tried my best to avoid making my own interpretations, and have generally been relaying my understanding of comments by lawyers on Twitter (e.g. https://twitter.com/ShipBrief/status/1355134952405397508). Writing my initial comment kind of forced me into a rabbit-hole of reading what people were saying...
[0] https://www.ft.com/content/5c15d7ea-aaf6-46f4-924e-30f168dd1...
You are completely misreading it. That's not at all what section 5.1 implies. Section 5.1 says AstraZeneca should make its best effort to manufacture in the EU after market approval. That's in opposition to improving and relying on foreign production something expressly permitted by the contract. That has no bearing on where the dose should come now.
> Section 5.4 which you quote from
That's the section about where the dose can come and point that all AstraZeneca production capacity are part of agreement.
But the real sinker for AstraZeneca is section 13.1.e.
"[AstraZeneca represents, warrants and covenants to the Commission and the Participating Member States that: ] it is not under any obligation, contractual or otherwise, to any Person or third party in respect of the Initial Europe Doses or that conflicts with or is inconsistent in any material respect with the terms of this Agreement or that would impede the complete fulfillment of its obligations under this Agreement;"
At this point, it is clear that AstraZeneca is trying to weasle out of its contractual obligation (unsurprisingly they are a pharma company after all). Short of an agreement being found and considering the EU doesn't have the time for a protractor trial, I think mandatory licensing or nationalisation of the production facilities are in order. But then again, this commission seems extremely weak so who knows.
> You are completely misreading it. That's not at all
> what section 5.1 implies.
What I wrote is a composite of a number of lawyer's comments on Twitter (e.g. https://twitter.com/FKeuleneer/status/1355138055305388036, https://twitter.com/BarristersHorse/status/13552864898113208..., https://twitter.com/SpinningHugo/status/1355486990150627329, and https://twitter.com/SBarrettBar/status/1355166944786264064). Do you have expertise that suggests that they are misreading?Searching around on Twitter, I've not yet been able to find legal opinions that say the Commission is in the right. Since you are apparently french, what are legal experts saying there? Perhaps they see it differently. Can you show me these opinions?
> But the real sinker for AstraZeneca is section 13.1.e.
>
> "[AstraZeneca represents, warrants and covenants to
> the Commission and the Participating Member States
> that: ] it is not under any obligation, contractual
> or otherwise, to any Person or third party in respect
> of the Initial Europe Doses or that conflicts with or
> is inconsistent in any material respect with the terms
> of this Agreement or that would impede the complete
> fulfillment of its obligations under this Agreement;"
It seems likely to me that (when taken in context of the rest of the contract) this actually proves the opposite of what you're saying. The most bullet-proof way that AstraZeneca could comply with this section is by segregating production of vaccines by country. There can be no conflicts between countries if vaccine allocations of initial doses are from separate factories. (I think the EU reading this as saying "there is no contract between AstraZeneca and the UK" is absolutely nonsensical since the UK's purchase order was widely publicised way before the EU signed.)Even if they're not letting on, I think it's likely that the Commission understands that they have a different allocation. Their actions show this -- they recently raided AstraZeneca's Belgian Vaccine Plant in an attempt to evidence the claim that AstraZeneca gave away EU doses to the UK. If AZ did this, that would have been an actual breach of 13.1.e of the contract.
A moment there I was worried my reading comprehension was failing me, thankfully none of the link you posted so authoritatively talk about section 5. They are mostly about down payments. Stop pretending you are posting a summary of things when you are talking about something else.
> It seems likely to me that (when taken in context of the rest of the contract) this actually proves the opposite of what you're saying. The most bullet-proof way that AstraZeneca could comply with this section is by segregating production of vaccines by country.
And what seems likely to you would be wrong. The contract says the opposite of what you are writing.
> I think the EU reading this as saying "there is no contract between AstraZeneca and the UK" is absolutely nonsensical since the UK's purchase order was widely publicised way before the EU signed
The EU experts wrote the contract. They don't have reading comprehension issue. AstraZeneca signed that their contract with the UK didn't contain conflicting obligations.
> AstraZeneca gave away EU doses to the UK
There are no EU doses and UK doses. AstraZeneca is manufacturing doses from different plants and has contractual obligations with multiple clients. The EU thinks their deliveries were mismanaged.
Everybody I posted has spoken about Section 5. Additionally at least one spoke about it in a link I posted. Your reading comprehension is failing you.
> The EU experts wrote the contract.
Interesting if true, but please source. I heard that it was Belgian Law.
> There are no EU doses and UK doses.
As I said, this is not what I've read.
In case you didn't notice, Belgium is part of the EU. The EU is not a jurisdiction for contract law. The contract will obviously have to rely on the law of one of the EU member state, here Belgium as it's where the comission is located.
> Interesting if true, but please source. I heard that it was Belgian Law.
EU commercial contracts are all drafted by EU civil servants i.e. EU experts. How do you think the EU works (apparently you don't have much idea)?
As I linked to earlier in the thread, the first Belgian lawyer I saw tweeting about the contract wrote "I cannot conclude that the Commission has [...] the right on its side. Quite the contrary." [0]
Another legal expert also recently wrote "[The European Commission appears to be wrong] Belgian lawyers so far seem to agree with this analysis." [1]
Finally, this Belgian lawyer also agrees [2] and gives more detail about why. He explains that "we have a classic distinction between obligations to achieve a result ("result") and obligations to use efforts ("means")" and that "using "best efforts", "reasonable efforts" or any other effort standard simply refers to an obligation of means".
I will not be the judge of this but I can say that I've yet to see a Belgian legal expert claiming anything like what you have. When you can't find a single expert to support your position that should be a red flag.
[0] https://twitter.com/FKeuleneer/status/1355138055305388036
[1] https://twitter.com/davidallengreen/status/13561494226866585...
[2] https://www.linkedin.com/posts/frcoppens_the-contract-betwee...
I assume a lot of people are reading it as “the EU is defined as just the U.K. for the purpose of this section” but you are right that it’s just saying “this section is about the U.K., not the EU”
Section 5.4 which you quote from specifies that "this section only shall include the United Kingdom". As written, this section does not relate to the distribution of the initial doses in Section 5.1, but instead is about where AstraZeneca _could_ choose to manufacture the vaccine. That is why it explains the process by which they might get prior written notice for non-EU manufacturing sites, and discusses how they could be contracted with if they are unable to deliver doses.
I think that gives them some leeway to ask AstraZeneca to increase capacity in the EU, but it strongly suggests to me that the capacity has meant to come from EU facilities, particularly for the "Initial Europe Doses".
Somebody also linked to this [1] which implies that AstraZeneca stated that they would have no other contracts that should conflict with the "Initial Europe Doses", however, I can imagine AstraZeneca will argue that this is achieved by segregating production in the initial doses stage and that the problem is due to low yields in the EU facilities and not due to competing arrangements.