Re:It’s time for police to stop lying to suspects
by valuearb on Friday January 29, 2021 @03:46PM
(#25962279)
I’m fine with cops lying if you’ve been charged with a crime, and established the antagonistic relationship, but not before.
When beat cops lie to ordinary citizens about what their rights are, it just builds up an enmity that makes it more difficult for community policing to work.
He points out that lying to suspects is both a tool and a risk - if you tell a suspect that there was blood found on his shoes, and the suspect knows that he wasn't wearing those shoes during the crime, he knows you have nothing.
I highlight this because it's fine and good to ban lying to suspects, but not all lies are strictly untrue, and it's possible to use partially true statements to one's benefit in an interrogation. Simon points out that interrogations, by their very nature, are coercive, and if we really want to protect the rights of suspects, mandating an attorney present at an interview is the only way to ensure that.