I think it would be a good idea to display the scores after you vote. That way you would know that you are upvoting a comment for it's merits, and it's not a case of mob mentality.
I think that would be more polarizing rather than less: You would have an incentive to vote one way or the other, even when you feel the comment deserves neither.
We could add a "+0" vote in addition of +1 and -1 votes to solve this problem.
A neutral vote ("I don't want to vote") should definitely be present, since many users don't have the ability to downvote (e.g. myself).
SHOUTING is a good way to get karma under the new system. It's rare for people to downvote, so comments that scream LOOK AT ME will get lots of upvotes.
Just as long as you don't overdo it, or say anything too controversial.
[1]http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2465271