News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores? by ZachPruckowski on Saturday May 28, 2011 @11:26PM (#2595897)
If we're using stars, why not base stars on comment percentile? Every night at midnight, take all the comment scores for the last week, and determine the 90th, 70th, 50th, and 30th percentiles. So every comment in the top 10% gets 5 stars, every comment in the top 30% but not in the top 10% has 4 stars, etc.

Also, I think we should switch it up so that comments are dimmed at more like -1 or -2. Otherwise, if the first vote is a downvote, people might overlook an otherwise decent (or controversial) comment.

Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores? by mishmash on Saturday May 28, 2011 @11:43PM (#2595937)
> Also, I think we should switch it up so that comments are dimmed at more like -1 or -2. Otherwise, if the first vote is a downvote, people might overlook an otherwise decent (or controversial) comment.

This is needed. I'm constantly upvoting valid, neutral things even if I don't really have an opinion on them simply because their first vote was down, likely by a disgruntled parent post.

Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores? by redthrowaway on Sunday May 29, 2011 @12:05AM (#2595977)
>likely by a disgruntled parent post.

You've never been able to downvote replies to your own comments.

Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores? by mishmash on Sunday May 29, 2011 @12:14AM (#2595989)
Oh wow 3 years and I've never noticed. Haha tells you've I've never tried to then. ;)
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores? by Smirnoff on Sunday May 29, 2011 @01:27PM (#2597026)
Unless they have a friend or a second account who can do it for them ;)
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores? by redthrowaway on Sunday May 29, 2011 @04:12PM (#2597460)
The karma threshold for downvoting comments is 500, iirc. That would make socking a fairly laborious prospect. As for meatpuppetry, if you're going to go through that much trouble just to downvote someone, then I'd suggest you have deeper issues.
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores? by Unseelie on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:22AM (#2596209)
I'm often drawn to greyed things, as they're different...not sure how prevalent that reaction is, but its at least a counterweight to overlook.
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores? by jasonlotito on Monday May 30, 2011 @10:10AM (#2599414)
Comment's should only reflect the current thread (well, everything underneath a news story). Not all stories receive the same traffic. A quality comment in one story might receive far less votes than a less quality comment in another story that is far more popular.

However, that is merely the method, and the idea of identifying quality stories is still sound.