Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores?
by mishmash on Saturday May 28, 2011 @10:36PM
(#2595794)
Seems complicated, just add meta-moderation.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores?
by JulianMorrison on Saturday May 28, 2011 @10:50PM
(#2595812)
How's it complicated? Meta moderation is much harder.
It would be a boolean flag in the comment that turns it into a trap. The operation of the trap is: set points = min(points, 1) and then if someone clicks upvote when points == 1, then rather than set points = 2, instead set karma=karma-100. Simple.
If so, combine it with either a short take-back period for votes or separation between the up and down arrows. Using a laptop, I've occasionally accidentally upvoted when I intended to downvote, and I understand that it is much more common to make such mistakes when using a touch-based interface.
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores?
by JulianMorrison on Saturday May 28, 2011 @11:14PM
(#2595871)
I've never understood why HN doesn't let you take back a moderation, not even in the way Google mail does (with an undo link popping up for a few seconds at the top of the screen).
I didn't mean the code would be complicated, but the additional mental load of all users evaluating every comment for it's trappiness (USERS * COMMENTS * SPLIT_SECOND).
If someone's being a jerk why not just use the current moderation/ban system that's in place? And if it's a specific idiotic/malicious set of characters that keeps popping up, just add a censor for it.
Pretty much all other moderation needs could be solved with slashcode-style meta-moderation.
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores?
by JulianMorrison on Sunday May 29, 2011 @12:20AM
(#2596000)
If you're the sort of person who naturally doesn't care to upvote stuff that the admins think ought to be booby-trapped, then you won't be stung. Versus, if you're a jerk who likes dumb comments, you'll be stung often enough to feel inhibition and a need to contemplate a comment's jerkiness and dumbness before hitting the up arrow. This additional mental load is quite deliberate.
Re:Poll: Should HN display comment scores?
by ZachPruckowski on Saturday May 28, 2011 @11:58PM
(#2595964)
Is meta-moderation useful when you can vote on as many comments as you'd like? It works on Slashdot because you can only moderate a handful of comments per day/week, but if you can moderate an infinite number of comments, you can create downvote-sink comments on an alternate account (or just make sure you downvote every actual troll), so that the majority (or a large minority) of your moderations pass meta-moderation.