Yeah I do really want the larger screen because of pdfs. My fire, and the other Kindles (non-Fire) I've used just make it a struggle to read pdfs on the device because of how small the screen size is.
Otherwise, thanks. I was already leaning towards the Onyx so this probably seals it.
It seems like you want a larger screen but if you’re fine with a smaller screen and no writing capability I recommend you get a dedicated ereader like a kindle; they really do excel at the ereading experience