Speaking specifically of my own lane, tech, I think you might underestimate how many people--particularly people of color--never make it into the "industry pipeline" because of lack of local opportunities. Those of us who came into the tech industry from the side in the 90s know the school doesn't make much difference at all in most jobs, it's just a predictor of whether you've otherwise prepared. The initial preparation tends to be self-driven, in the best employees, and they exist everywhere. The biggest differentiator comes down to whether someone gives you a shot, and that’s almost entirely about contacts and location for name-brand-company SWE positions.
However much competition there will be then, there's more now with everything chunked up. We're talking about an existing situation. Widening the applicant pool to cheaper applicants can't do anything but help an employer.
Yet somehow firms do OK with the people they manage to hire.
So maybe firms could just be less fearful of hiring, attract equal talent, and get on with life.
I doubt that I'd be considered an A player. My employer already makes productive use of talent in the Midwest, but we are not predominantly a software company.
Also, there's plenty of C-level talent in the bay. You can pay the same and get B+ or better in an inland state.
How many are there, though, really?
And what happens when you now have to compete with _every_other_company_ that also wants to hire them?
They'll make more money, good for them. But the majority of companies will just have to settle for hiring C-level talent.