Re:On Chomsky and the Two Cultures of Statistical Learning
by burgerbrain on Friday May 27, 2011 @05:27PM
(#2593132)
"No one, as far as I know, argues that humans actually solve differential equations in their head when they catch a ball."
I would argue that we actually find approximate solutions to differential equations with what is likely best described as an analog computer.
So essentially, humans and computers as they are currently programmed do it the same way. The only difference is that computers do it better.
Re:On Chomsky and the Two Cultures of Statistical Learning
by scott_s on Friday May 27, 2011 @05:49PM
(#2593202)
By actually I meant solve them in the same way that you and I solve them; analytically, using our formalisms. Rather, I'm proposing that our brains are using some statistical model that gives results pretty damn close to what the analytical answers would be. And that something similar is true for syntax and grammar.
Re:On Chomsky and the Two Cultures of Statistical Learning
by burgerbrain on Friday May 27, 2011 @08:28PM
(#2593557)
Eh, a computer is a computer.
No one, as far as I know, argues that humans actually solve differential equations in their head when they catch a ball. They just... catch it. Perhaps with some failed attempts along the way, but as a part of growing up, we learned basic eye-hand coordination.
The notion that syntax and grammar as we have formalized it exist in our brains is the same as saying that differential equations exist in our brains. I find it much more likely that we innately have rough models for syntax, grammar, mechanical movement and object trajectories, but that it takes significant trial-and-error for us to tune those models until the point of competence. I think these models have to be at least partly statistical - otherwise, we wouldn't need to learn anything - and that while our formalisms may be nice approximations of what we do in our brains, I see no reason why they have to be exactly it.