As we can see now this was not only foolish but self-destructive. The only scenario where I see this paying off is when GameStop went bankrupt and there was no sign for this at all.
People love when greed gets punished and this is what we are seeing here.
But even disregarding that, a hedge fund’s job is literally to manage risk using more complex financial instruments.
A complacent hedge fund that overextends itself don’t just need to fail, they need to burn long and hard
Sadly, they usually get “bailed” out (by their buddies in their industry, not the government), like we just saw with Melvin. Which in turn creates enormous inefficiencies in our economy..
Why so?
They're based on asymmetry of information, the shorter having more insight than the lender. And their purpose is to convert that information into money at the lender's expense; by the time he gets his shares back, they've tanked.
There are obviously problems with who actually has access to short stocks, but in theory they are a reasonable counterbalance:
If you believe in the stock, buy it, if you don’t believe in it sell it.
And if you don’t currently own any shares, you can borrow shares from the people who believe in the stock, sell them now and cash out when/if the stock goes down.
The information imbalance is fundamentally a part of how we operate our markets, since information literally can’t instantly be distributed to everyone (regardless of what faith-based “economists” try to convince people to believe about the efficient market gospel)
They seem to think that shorts = bad.