If his methods are discredited, you can't really conclude anything from it. The fact that he didn't prove one thing doesn't by default prove the opposite, it just means he didn't prove the original thing.
No. Milgram's experiment being discredited means that we should revert back to the "we don't know what average person does".
If you want to conclude that "the average person will revolt against an unjust authority" you will need to make multiple valid experiments to confirm that first. And you should not forget that peoples behavior is strongly influenced by cultures they are in, so you will also need to account for that.
> therefore we should interpret a lack of pervasive popular revolt as a sign of justness and legitimacy of the authorities
Slavery used to be considered just and legitimate. Slavery is not considered just and legitimate. "justness and legitimacy" are not scientific terms.
We see what people do every day. We don’t need experiments to show us. Just pay attention.
"Shock that person, please."
"What? No."
"I forgot to mention, he said he wants to steal your job and sell drugs to your kids"
"Thank you for giving me a chance to shock that person. I'm glad you were here to keep me safe."
Hey loved followers: "Those evil legislators are trying to steal the election. We need to defend our liberty."
History has repeatedly shown that a significant number of people will actively play along and almost nobody will revolt. Otherwise the Nazi war crimes and Holocaust, My Lai, the purges and gulags under Stalin or the Khmer Rouge wouldn’t have happened. All these needed significant participation from a lot of average people. History also shows that no culture (as in religion or a certain part of the world) is immune from that.
Yes, but in all those cases, average people were someone who already went though a lot of indoctrination/propaganda. And average person was also under considerable danger he she/he defects. Average person both believed a lot of ideology and also feared for himself/herself/family. The general leaders of those were powerful players who actively believed their ideologies.
The purges and gulags under Stalin were very from-top organized. They did not just impulsively went into it without planning. Instead, they made sure you have no realistic way to stop anything and that you do believe victims are the bad ones in the first place.
That being said, Holocaust itself happened mostly in occupied territories when the German army had pretty much perfect control over the place. The average person was not much of a player, the military organized and backed it basically.
I'd like to ask you though, who exactly sent in all those millions of complaints about "enemies of the people"?
1.) Purges specifically had quotas for areas. If you refused to cooperate, you and your familly was purged. Specifically purges gave little good choice to participants. You literally had to participate or die.
Wish to stay alive was frequent motivating factor. I will quote myself: average people were someone who already went though a lot of indoctrination/propaganda. And average person was also under considerable danger he she/he defects. Average person both believed a lot of ideology and also feared for himself/herself/family. The general leaders of those were powerful players who actively believed their ideologies.
3.) Your mythical average person outside of system and culture does not exists. "The average person" is living inside totalitarian system where opposing the system meant severe retaliation for years. It also means that if you oppose system, you are isolated and can't organize opposition.
Nazi spend years trying to teach people, average Germans, that empathy toward emnemy is weakness. That manly men fight, are ruthless and kill enemies without empathy. The cruelty you see in WWII is also felt of pre exiasting belief in those Germans that what they do is right.
The people of that time did not shared your values.
"Nobody else seems to have a problem with it, it must be just you. Help is available for people struggling with mental health issues and change is sometimes uncomfortable, especially for people accustomed to privilege, maybe it's time for some self-care, citizen..."