Re:Studies That Show Lockdowns Are Ineffective at Slowing Co...
by baash05 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:11AM
(#25926363)
Nah.. don't buy it. Here in Australia we tried em. We did them hard, and right, and then we had zero's. Zero cases in 10 days, and less than 1000 dead total.
If they don't work, what are we doing right?
Re:Studies That Show Lockdowns Are Ineffective at Slowing Co...
by aceflux on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:23AM
(#25926437)
Lower population density. Less complexity in our systems due to lower population. Relatively less diverse culture compared to US/UK so easier to mass disseminate rule of law. More sympathetic culture to follow bureaucracy than Southern European nations.
Re:Studies That Show Lockdowns Are Ineffective at Slowing Co...
by aceflux on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:32AM
(#25926505)
An article published on Nature journal is the holy grail of biomedical research. Like this one, titled "Estimating the effects of non-pharmaceutical interventions on COVID-19 in Europe"
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2405-7
It fits the bill bill and states "Lockdown has an identifiable large effect on transmission (81% (75–87%) reduction)"
Not a popular statement to make, but it is what it is.
Re:Studies That Show Lockdowns Are Ineffective at Slowing Co...
by Someone on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:06AM
(#25926750)
I think this mostly conflates main factors affecting how hard covid-19 hits with things governments can do in the short term to contain it. Factors such as obesity and average GDP correlate much stronger with lethality, but you can’t turn those knobs overnight.
Also, I don’t think all of these say lockdowns are ineffective. The lancet study (#1 from the article) says “full lockdowns… were significantly associated with increased patient recovery rates.”
That means they can make the difference between being able to give all patients the care they need and overloaded hospitals.
Also, I don’t read that lockdowns are ineffective in #3. In my reading, it (more) says that, if you do a lockdown, you better do it fast, as that means you can keep it limited.
Re:Studies That Show Lockdowns Are Ineffective at Slowing Co...
by nness on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:41AM
(#25926559)
fee.org — "The Foundation for Economic Education (FEE) is a libertarian economic think-tank in the United States dedicated to the "economic, ethical and legal principles of a free society."
Have you been to Australia? Besides being misinformed, this is low-key bigoted.
It fits the bill bill and states "Lockdown has an identifiable large effect on transmission (81% (75–87%) reduction)"
Not a popular statement to make, but it is what it is.
Also, I don’t think all of these say lockdowns are ineffective. The lancet study (#1 from the article) says “full lockdowns… were significantly associated with increased patient recovery rates.”
That means they can make the difference between being able to give all patients the care they need and overloaded hospitals.
Also, I don’t read that lockdowns are ineffective in #3. In my reading, it (more) says that, if you do a lockdown, you better do it fast, as that means you can keep it limited.
Read, not an authoritative source.