Moreover, rule-based NLP approaches also have their place, and they are often the direct result of theoretical advances. A case in point is the modelling of morphophonology (which is necessary for spell checking, dictionaries and text generation for morphologically complex languages): many successful approaches are those based on finite-state machines, which could not have happened without Johnson and later Koskenniemi using them to formalize the rule-based approach pioneered by Halle and (yes) Chomsky (well, not quite, but this is still the point of reference for rule-based phonology).
(I am a theoretical phonologist, but my colleagues who do actual NLP work of this type tell me that statistical methods aren't that great for the sort of work they do.)
That technology is impressive to the utmost degree, I just don't think it should be the endgoal of modern science.
We should look for it, but we should not expect to find it.
I'd agree that an adhoc equation that fits observed core sample data doesn't provide an intellectually satisfying model for "how sedimentation works", but you don't need to have a model for "how sedimentation works" in order to use it.
That's actually from something I worked on a long time ago. People actually use adhoc models of sedimentation and the formation of sedimentary rock for practical purposes. I also think most people suspect that we'd learn something valuable by figuring out the underlying reason why the data fits the particular description.
From an engineering standpoint, however, Chomsky's view of grammar has been remarkably barren when it comes to machine processing of natural language. It's made a major contribution to artificial languages but despite a lot of effort it hasn't added much performance to what can be done with statistical methods.
I'd agree that a hidden Markov model that does POS tagging with high accuracy doesn't provide an intellectually satisfying model for "how language works", but you don't need to have a model for "how language works" in order to use it.