Re:On Chomsky and the Two Cultures of Statistical Learning
by adavies42 on Friday May 27, 2011 @03:38PM
(#2592794)
i saw someone once compare chomsky to freud, as a foundational figure whose discipline can't/couldn't progress during his lifetime.
Chomsky is a colossus, his achievements are well-known. However, at one point in many disciplines it comes to pass that the pioneers who pave the way in time become the very impediment to new ideas. His emphasis on Semantics have warped the minds of many generations of researchers (and some other ideas on universal grammar, too).
I experienced this first hand, my advisor, Prof. Raskin, a great researcher on semantics, nevertheless thought that statistical approaches were not the way to go. Sadly, in many Linguistics departments people are just not equipped with the statistical tools necessary to have a basic understand of what's being done in the NLP field. So NLP is generally taught under CS, EE, or CompE.