I feel the same way. What's present in TFA isn't enough to convince me of anything.
What I'm concerned about is this: how does this work with quantum weirdness such as post-selection and entanglement? If I had answers to those questions I might understand what they're proposing. (With a peer-class time dimension I can imagine those two effects in non-spooky ways. Without it they seem hopelessly spooky.)
I can't tell if they are proposing something new, or just trying to change some of the vocabulary and mental models we use for current physics.