I think social media has taught us that most people are terrible diplomats. Which is to expected when a person’s threat response is engaged. Having a thick skinned and measured reaction to threat is still the best way to reduce that threat. And it requires a level of discomfort unprivileged people are generally much better at dealing with; the people who need to hear that advice most are those advantaged enough to be unfamiliar with dealing with discomfort.
I think a better solution than forcing everyone to become diplomatic or banning those who violate the norms of others is to have somewhat siloed social groups that are represented by open minded thick skinned diplomatic types that permeate the borders. That’s part of what’s appealing about a federated model; I think it better mirrors our social tendencies and historically successful political systems with diverse constituents (representative republics seem to be the only proven systems capable of dealing with lots of different peoples long term).
I’m of the opinion that the most virulent partisanship is actually due to the lack of silos rather than the echo chamber narrative. Before the internet, in group conversations stayed behind closed doors. That privacy allowed people who would be outraged at the contents of those conversations to get along in a diplomatic middle.
Now those conversations are public, and people seem to be fighting over control of one big room where all the walls have been removed.
This is a genuinely fascinating idea that I haven’t seen before in discussion around Mastodon & co.
Not convinced it’s an actual possibility because of a lack of scarce resources & the like to actually cause diplomacy to happen over in a familiar way, but I have 0 idea of what the fediverse is like from within the fediverse, so perhaps there is something there I’m just not aware of.
Would upvote and read an insider’s “Diplomacy in the Age of Federation” esque article in a heartbeat.
Because it's what makes society possible.
In general Americans seem to be more thick-skinned than others. Or at least we used to be.
EDIT: Here you go buddy... this is almost a word-for-word of the argument that was used in the actual Supreme Court case, and should illustrate why we're at such a dangerous time in history - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MeTuNES82O0
Selection bias. I'd think that's how people you happen to hang out with, or talk with on the internet, might be.
But not people in general, at least not the ones I've met from the US (lots of people).
Check out the book Infamous Scribblers: The Founding Fathers and the Rowdy Beginnings of American Journalism.
> I'd think that's how people you happen to hang out with, or talk with on the internet, might be.
You literally have no data to support that comment, whereas I'm referencing existing documents throughout American history that show just how vitriolic communications were.
You realize that our politicians used to get into fistfights on the floor of Congress, right?
> But not people in general, at least not the ones I've met from the US (lots of people).
What you've just described is selection bias, but I understand why would you feel that way. You're likely not exposed to a diverse selection of Americans. Do you know many corn farmers from the Midwest states? Do you know any deep sea welders from Mississippi? Do you know many club promoters from California? Do you know many book editors from New York?
> referencing existing documents throughout American history that show just how vitriolic communications were.
> Do you know many corn farmers from the Midwest states? Do you know any deep sea welders from ...
Maybe you're right that those groups of people more often communicate in the ways you say.
At the same time, maybe they do also in Mexico or Italy or Kongo and in lots of other countries too.
So the examples doesn't really mean anything to me. Thanks anyway for explaining how you were thinking.
The US is a large country and by cherry picking examples one can "prove" anything one wants.
Actually we need the rest of social media to have this, and then we don't need these alternative platforms.
There are simply too many people who have grown up without having any meaningful opposition in their lives - without having someone challenge their ideas and values and making them defend said ideas and values, and they simply do. not. know. how to cope with it.