Re:Czech trainers teach dogs to sniff out Covid: 95-percent ...
by coliveira on Sunday January 24, 2021 @12:33PM
(#25893851)
why do your think this the the work of a journalist? If this is important, then we should have some regulation saying how companies need to report experiments.
Re:Czech trainers teach dogs to sniff out Covid: 95-percent ...
by virgilp on Sunday January 24, 2021 @01:18PM
(#25894258)
well, for starters, it's published on france24.com, that's a pretty good hint that it is the work of a journalist.
I believe one shouldn't regulate _all speech_ (e.g. company press releases, or scientific publications); but I think it's fair to regulate reporting, to some extent. And you can even have a somewhat wide definition of "reporting" (e.g. if you collect audience size metrics (e.g. in order to get revenue from advertising), and your audience is greater than X, then you are reporting).
Re:Czech trainers teach dogs to sniff out Covid: 95-percent ...
by nanis on Sunday January 24, 2021 @02:38PM
(#25895066)
It is the job of the journalist to at least be able to ask "what do you mean by 95% accuracy?" and to publish the answer given or the fact that no satisfactory answer is given because the reader is not in a position to be able to ask that question to the entity whose results are being publicized.
I would argue that's one of the problems. It's easy to just regurgitate press briefing, but that's _not_ what their job should be. I'd argue they could at the very least impose some form standards (don't publish "x% success", ask for exact metrics before publishing the press briefing). Asking them to vet that the study methodology was sane is too much - but asking them to use specificity & sensitivity instead of "success percent" isn't too much to ask.